• Front of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2153, Polk's Infirmary, on a sidewalk on DeWeese Street in Lexington
    Reverse of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2153, Mammoth Insurance Co., on DeWeese Street in Lexington

    “Dr. John Polk, an African American physician in Lexington, practiced medicine at 166 Deweese St. before moving to 148 Deweese by 1921. Succeeding him in this building was Dr. J. R. Dalton. The infirmary served African Americans in area. In 1999, this former health center became the home of Lexington-Fayette County Urban League.”

    “Founded 1915 in Louisville, Mammoth Life and Accident Ins. Co. opened district office at 149 Deweese. It offered employment opportunities and fair rates to African American community. At its peak, Mammoth had 750 employees and sold policies in eight states. In 1992 Mammoth merged with Atlanta Life and the Kentucky offices closed.”

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2153 — dedicated September 12, 2004; presented by the Lexington-Fayette Co. Urban League

    149 Deweese St., Lexington | 38° 02′ 40″ N, 84° 29′ 30″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    Marker No. 2153 stands on a short stretch of DeWeese Street, between a two-story brick building at 148 and a small one-story house at 149. Its two sides tell what look like two separate stories. One is about a doctor. The other is about an insurance company. Read together, they describe the same thing: a Black neighborhood building the institutions that white Lexington would not provide.

    In the 1920s a Black family in Lexington who needed a hospital bed, or a life insurance policy, could not count on getting either from the city’s white-run institutions. On this block they could get both, from people who looked like them, on either side of the street. The brick building at 148 DeWeese was Polk’s Infirmary. Today it is the office of the Urban League of Lexington-Fayette County, a community service organization founded in 1968, in the words of its original charter, “to secure equal opportunity for negroes and other disadvantaged citizens,” through work in housing, education, and employment. Across the street was the local office of a Louisville company founded, in its own words, as “an insurance company of, by, and for Negros in Kentucky.”

    A Preacher’s Son from Woodford County

    Newspaper portrait of Dr. John Knox Polk, a Black man in a dark suit, white collar, and bow tie, shown in three-quarter profile
    Dr. John Knox Polk, from his obituary in the Lexington Herald, March 19, 1936.

    John Knox Polk was born in Woodford County in 1882. His father, James Knox Polk, had been born enslaved in 1845 at Bosque Bonita, a Woodford County horse farm that is now part of Lane’s End Farm near Versailles. His mother named him after the newly elected president. Bosque Bonita was well known in racing circles: Leamington, the sire of Aristides, winner of the first Kentucky Derby, stood at stud there. The farm’s owner, Abraham Buford, later a Confederate cavalry general, took him to war as a hostler, caring for the horses. After the war James Polk came home, married, and became a Baptist preacher. In 1872 he founded Pilgrim Baptist Church in Midway, Kentucky, and for 45 years he pastored a church in Mortonsville, Kentucky, that was later renamed Polk Memorial in his honor.

    The son grew up in that household. The 1900 census shows the family on Lexington Street in Versailles, and John attended the town’s colored common school. He trained first in pharmacy and then in medicine. According to his obituary in the Lexington Herald, he completed a pharmaceutical course and went on to earn his degrees at Roger Williams University in Nashville, Tennessee and at Howard University in Washington, D.C. He came to Lexington to practice in 1914, and that year’s city directory lists “Polk, John K., 166 Deweese” under Physicians, on the same page as Dr. John E. Hunter and the city’s other Black doctors. The UK HealthCare marker says he graduated from Howard in 1918 and only then opened his practice, but the directories and his obituary both show him at work four years earlier. In September 1918, at 36, Polk registered for the World War I draft. He gave his occupation as physician and his office as 166 DeWeese, and he signed the card “J. K. Polk, M.D.” His father died that same January.

    In 1920 Polk dedicated a new building a short way down the block at number 148, an office, hospital, and home together, which the Herald later valued at $20,000. He called it Polk’s Infirmary. The city directories still place him at 166 in 1919 and at 148 by 1921, which matches the state marker’s “by 1921.” A little more than half a century after his father came home from the Civil War, the son of a man born into slavery was running a small hospital of his own.

    Why a Black Doctor Needed His Own Hospital

    The infirmary existed because the alternatives were so limited. In the early twentieth century, Black physicians in Lexington, as in most of the South, could not join the staffs of the large hospitals. Black patients were admitted only on segregated terms. St. Joseph Hospital, run by the Sisters of Charity of Nazareth, kept Black patients in a separate building. Dr. John E. Hunter, who came to Lexington in 1889, became the first Black surgeon to operate at St. Joseph, an exception that depended on the support of the hospital’s longtime administrator, Sister Euphrasia Stafford.

    For most Black doctors, the answer was to build their own. Small private infirmaries like Polk’s gave Black physicians a place to treat and house patients, and gave Black patients a place where they would be cared for without being sent to the back building of a whites-only hospital. A few blocks away, at 118 North Broadway, an office building housed several of the city’s Black physicians and a pharmacy in the same years. It has its own KHS marker, No. 1928, “African American Physicians.”

    The Infirmary at 148 DeWeese

    Two-story brick building at 148 DeWeese Street with white trim, a front stoop, and an Urban League sign on the lawn
    148 DeWeese Street, dedicated as Polk’s Infirmary in 1920 and home of the Urban League of Lexington-Fayette County since 1999.

    Polk’s Infirmary was more than a doctor’s office. The 1931 city directory lists it as a business at 148 DeWeese, and when census takers came through Lexington in 1930, they listed “Polk’s Infirmary” as an institution in its enumeration district, the category used for hospitals and other places where people lived under care. The Polk-Dalton Pharmacy operated in the same building. The UK HealthCare marker calls the infirmary “the center for Lexington’s African-American community,” a phrase that suggests it served as a gathering place as well as a place for care. Polk was also a leader among his colleagues: he belonged to the state and local medical societies and served as president in 1931 and 1932.

    Older physicians later recalled that his health had shown signs of heart trouble since he was young. In the spring of 1935, after special treatment in Cleveland, Ohio, for his heart, he went to Lakeland, Florida, with his wife, Annie Chandler Polk, and his family, hoping the climate would help. He died there on March 11, 1936, at 53. His body came home to Lexington and lay in state at the Edward W. Jackson funeral home, which by then occupied “the Polk building, 148 Deweese street.” His funeral at First Baptist Church, where he was a member, was “largely attended,” the Herald’s “Colored Notes” column reported, and he was buried in Greenwood Cemetery. The Woodford Sun, the newspaper of the county where he grew up, ran the news under the headline “Dr. John Polk Dies.”

    Dr. Dalton, from Georgetown to DeWeese Street

    The front of the marker says simply, “Succeeding him in this building was Dr. J. R. Dalton.” Neither marker gives his first name, and the published accounts disagree about when he arrived. Census records, draft cards, and city directories fill in the story.

    His name was J. Rufus Dalton, Joe Rufus on his draft card. He was born in Huntingdon, Tennessee, on June 1, 1894, according to his 1942 draft registration, though his death certificate gives 1896 and Illinois. By 1920 he was a practicing physician and surgeon in Georgetown, in neighboring Scott County, married to Anna Dell Dalton. He was still in Georgetown in 1930, in a house he owned on West Jefferson Street, and in 1940, when he told the census taker he had worked 72 hours the week before.

    That record settles a question the sources disagree on. The Notable Kentucky African Americans Database says Dalton joined Polk in 1931, but in 1930 and 1940 he was living and practicing in Georgetown. The UK HealthCare marker’s version fits the records better. After Polk left for Florida, the building at 148 DeWeese housed a funeral home, and in 1940 Dalton reopened it as a medical practice. By 1943 the Lexington City Directory lists “J. Rufus Dalton, physician and surgeon,” at 148 DeWeese, and he is listed there through the early 1950s. The 1950 census shows him in Lexington with Anna and their sons, James and Rufus, still a doctor with his own practice.

    In September 1953, the Louisville Defender reported that Dr. J. R. Dalton, “noted Lexington physician,” had died of a heart attack while on his way home to Cairo, Illinois. His death certificate places his death on September 10, in Nelson County, somewhere along the road west. Like Polk, he was buried from First Baptist Church in Lexington. Between them, the two doctors kept 148 DeWeese open as a medical office for nearly three decades, with a four-year gap after Polk’s death.

    The Insurance Office Across the Street

    The reverse of the marker turns to 149 DeWeese, the district office of the Mammoth Life and Accident Insurance Company.

    Small one-story blue cottage with a front-gabled roof and white porch railing at 149 DeWeese Street
    149 DeWeese Street, once the Lexington district office of Mammoth Life and Accident Insurance Company.

    Mammoth was founded in Louisville in 1915. The Filson Historical Society, which holds the company’s records, names four founders: Henry E. Hall, William H. Wright, B. O. Wilkerson, and Rochelle I. Smith. Hall and Wright served as its first co-presidents. Companies like Mammoth grew up in what historians call the golden age of Black business, in the decades when segregation shut Black customers out of white-owned institutions or served them on worse terms. Many white insurers either refused Black customers or sold them smaller policies at higher rates. A Black-owned company could promise what the marker calls “fair rates.”

    Mammoth spread quickly. After its first Louisville office in 1915, it added branch offices in Paducah, Lexington, Hopkinsville, and Bowling Green, and by 1928 it had district offices in seven other states: Michigan, Illinois, Indiana, Ohio, Missouri, Tennessee, and Wisconsin. That accounts for the marker’s “eight states.” It also gave office and sales jobs to Black men and women at a time when few other employers in Kentucky would. By the late 1920s, Mammoth was advertising to Black Lexington in the Lexington Herald‘s “Colored Notes” column: “For Protection and Prosperity Insure With the Mammoth Life & Accident Insurance Company.”

    Newspaper advertisement reading For Protection and Prosperity Insure With the Mammoth Life and Accident Insurance Company
    Mammoth Life advertisement, “Colored Notes,” Lexington Herald, October 28, 1928.

    The end came slowly. As segregation eased, Black customers had more choices, and Black-owned insurers were bought up by larger firms. In 1992 Atlanta Life Insurance Company, a Black-owned firm based in Georgia, took control of Mammoth. The marker calls it a merger; the Filson describes Atlanta Life as having brought Mammoth under its control. By 1994 the old Louisville flagship office had closed, and with it the Kentucky offices.

    “Do As You Please Street”

    The doctor and the insurance office were not alone. By the late nineteenth century, DeWeese Street was the center of a mostly Black residential and business district in Lexington’s East End. Some residents called it the “do as you please street.” Segregation and discriminatory real estate practices had pushed Black families into closely built shotgun houses here, and the businesses followed the people: grocery and clothing stores, barbershops and beauty shops, funeral homes, nightclubs, and insurance offices. The Lyric Theatre opened nearby in December 1948 and anchored the district’s entertainment for decades.

    Integration, beginning in the 1950s, changed the street. Businesses that had depended on segregated customers moved away or closed, and insurance companies like Mammoth were absorbed by larger firms. In 1964 Black residents and their allies defeated a federal urban renewal plan for the East End in a public referendum, after officials failed to show how displaced families would be rehoused. Later redevelopment still cleared much of the old street. In 2018 the KHS added a second marker, No. 2562, “Deweese (Dewees) St. Neighborhood,” at Third Street and Elm Tree Lane, to tell the story of the district as a whole.

    A Clinic That Carries Their Names

    The infirmary building did not disappear. In 1999 the Lexington-Fayette County Urban League made 148 DeWeese its home, and five years later the League presented this marker.

    The story has one more chapter, told on a different kind of marker around the corner. In 1996 the University of Kentucky opened Kentucky Clinic North to provide primary care in what it called “a medically underserved area of downtown Lexington.” The clinic moved into a newly constructed building at Third Street and Elm Tree Lane in 2000. On April 21, 2008, UK HealthCare renamed it the Polk-Dalton Clinic, and put up its own blue marker explaining why. A university clinic now carries the names of two doctors who practiced when Lexington’s large hospitals were closed to them, a few hundred feet from where they worked.

    Blue University of Kentucky HealthCare marker titled Polk-Dalton Clinic on a lawn
    Entrance of the Polk-Dalton Clinic, a red brick building with a white columned portico

    The UK HealthCare marker (2008) and the Polk-Dalton Clinic on Elm Tree Lane.

    Reading Both Sides

    Many two-sided markers carry one story from front to back. This one carries two that turn out to be one. On a single block of DeWeese Street, a doctor and an insurance company offered the two things segregation made hardest to get: a bed and a physician when someone was sick, and something to leave behind when someone died. Neither was charity. Both were businesses, built by Black Lexingtonians for Black Lexingtonians, at a time when the city’s white institutions either turned them away or served them on worse terms.

    John Polk’s life spans that whole arc. His father was born the property of another man and spent the Civil War caring for that man’s horses. Within fifty years of the war’s end, the son was listed among Lexington’s physicians, and by 1921 he had a hospital of his own. Neither side of the marker mentions that, and neither says what became of the street around it. What remains are two buildings facing each other, a marker between them, and a university clinic around the corner that now carries Polk’s name. Standing between number 148 and number 149, a reader can still see what this community built for itself when no one else would.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker database, Marker No. 2153 (Polk’s Infirmary / Mammoth Insurance Co.), Marker No. 2562 (Deweese (Dewees) St. Neighborhood), and Marker No. 1928 (African American Physicians), with the ExploreKYHistory entry for No. 1928; UK HealthCare, Polk-Dalton Clinic marker (2008), and Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org) entries 169744, 169746, and 169747; Notable Kentucky African Americans Database, University of Kentucky: “Polk, John Knox,” “Polk, James Knox (former enslaved man),” and “St. Joseph Hospital (Lexington, KY),” with the sources they cite, including “Dr. John Polk Dies,” Woodford Sun (March 19, 1936), “Markers celebrate Deweese Street history,” Lexington Herald-Leader (September 13, 2004), “Clinic named for 2 black doctors,” Lexington Herald-Leader (March 5, 2008), and Who’s Who in Colored America (1927); 1930 U.S. Census, Fayette County enumeration district descriptions (us-census.org); Filson Historical Society, “Mammoth Life and Accident Insurance Company” online exhibit; Kentucky Health Information, “Kentucky’s African American Men and Women of Medicine” (2020); Blue Grass Trust for Historic Preservation, Tour the Historic Bluegrass, “Deweese Street”; Segregated Lexington project, “Urban Renewal: East End.”; Lexington city directories (R. L. Polk & Co.), 1914, 1919, 1921, 1931, and 1943–1954, via Ancestry.com; U.S. World War I Draft Registration Card, John Knox Polk (September 12, 1918); U.S. World War II Draft Registration Card, Joe Rufus Dalton (1942); U.S. Federal Census, 1920, 1930, 1940, and 1950 (J. Rufus Dalton); Kentucky death certificate, Rufus Dalton (September 10, 1953); “Dr. J. K. Polk,” Lexington Herald (March 19, 1936); “Colored Notes,” Lexington Herald (March 21, 1936); “Heart Attack Fatal to Dr. J. R. Dalton,” Louisville Defender (September 24, 1953); “Colored Notes,” Lexington Herald (October 28, 1928).

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Listen to this story

    Narration is AI-generated from the text of this article.

    “Here on May 14, 1825, General LaFayette was entertained by Major John Keene who had served as his Aide-De-Camp during the Revolutionary War.”

    The Keeneland historical marker in front of a stone wall and white board fence on Versailles Road

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2 — erected by the Historical Markers Society of Lexington, 1936

    4201 Versailles Rd. (US 60), Lexington | 38° 02′ 36″ N, 84° 35′ 59″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    Marker No. 2 stands at the edge of one of the most famous racetracks in the world, and it says nothing about horses. It is about a guest. In May 1825 the Marquis de Lafayette, the French nobleman who had fought for American independence as a teenager, spent a night on this land on his way into Lexington. Fayette County had been named for him in 1780, when he was twenty-three. This was the only time he ever saw it. The plaque is old, too. It was the second historical marker put up in Kentucky, placed by a private Lexington group, the Historical Markers Society, in the spring of 1936; the first went up at Lexington’s Ashland Estate. The marker stood on the Versailles pike before the racetrack did. Keeneland held its first races that October.

    The plaque is one sentence long, and one of its details does not hold up well: the claim that his host had been Lafayette’s aide-de-camp cannot be true. Its date is also a day early. The visit itself is real and well documented, and so is the house where it happened. That house is still here, on the Keeneland grounds, where the track’s grounds map labels it Keene Place.

    The Nation’s Guest

    Painted portrait of a young Lafayette in a dark blue general's uniform with gold embroidery, holding a rolled paper
    Lafayette as a lieutenant general in 1791, painted by Joseph-Désiré Court in 1834 (Palace of Versailles; public domain).

    Lafayette came back to the United States in August 1824 at the invitation of President James Monroe, as the country approached the fiftieth anniversary of independence. He was sixty-six. He had been nineteen when he joined the Continental Army in 1777, and he had been wounded at the Battle of Brandywine, fought along Brandywine Creek southwest of Philadelphia, that September. As a teenage major general he had been younger than most of the men he led. Nearly fifty years later, the soldiers who had followed him were in their sixties, seventies, and eighties, and most of them were already gone. Americans treated him as a living link to the generation that had founded the country.

    His tour lasted more than a year. Lafayette traveled with his son, George Washington Lafayette, and his secretary, Auguste Levasseur, who kept a detailed journal of the trip, published in 1829 as the book Lafayette in America in 1824 and 1825. Together they visited all twenty-four states in the union. To thank him, and because he had lost much of his fortune during the French Revolution, Congress gave him $200,000 and a 36-square-mile tract of public land near to Tallahassee, in the Florida Territory. He never visited. French settlers he sent there in the 1830s found the climate too hot and soon left, and by 1855 the land had been sold off in pieces. Today it lies within Tallahassee, where Lake Lafayette and the Lafayette Oaks neighborhood carry his name. During his tour, towns competed to host him with parades, dinners, balls, and triumphal arches, most of them temporary structures of wood and cloth built for the celebration.

    The western leg of the tour was harder than the eastern one. Around midnight on May 8, 1825, on a dark and rainy night, the steamboat Mechanic, carrying Lafayette’s party down the Ohio River toward Louisville, struck a submerged log, called a snag, near what is now Cannelton, Indiana, and sank. Snags were among the most common causes of steamboat wrecks on western rivers. Everyone reached shore, but Lafayette lost money and belongings, and the party waited on the riverbank until another steamboat, the Paragon, picked them up the next day. He reached Louisville on May 11.

    Sunday on the Versailles Road

    From Louisville, Lafayette went to Frankfort, where he attended a dinner and a ball on May 14. The next morning, Sunday, May 15, the party left Frankfort for Lexington by way of Versailles. Lafayette did not usually travel on the Sabbath, but he made an exception. The roads were wet and the weather was poor. The road east from Versailles had no formal name; like most Lexington roads at the time, it was simply called for the town it led to. It was still a dirt road. Kentucky built its first crushed-stone toll road, from Lexington to Maysville, in 1830, and over the next few decades most of the roads out of Lexington were rebuilt the same way and became known as turnpikes, or “pikes.”

    Column of 1825 newspaper text headed Lafayette's Visit, describing the rainy weather and muddy roads before his arrival
    “Lafayette’s Visit,” Kentucky Gazette, May 19, 1825.

    He spent that night about five miles outside Lexington, at the brick house of John and Mary “Polly” Keen, while his military escort camped on the grounds. The next morning a county committee called on him there, and Colonel Leslie Combs, a Lexington lawyer and War of 1812 veteran, read its address of welcome. Lafayette then rode toward Lexington in a four-horse carriage, with Abraham Bowman beside him.

    Engraved portrait of Leslie Combs, a man with dark wavy hair, arms folded, wearing a high collar and cravat
    Leslie Combs (1793–1881), from Benson Lossing’s Pictorial Field-Book of the War of 1812 (1869).

    There is a family story behind the choice of house. According to the history told at Keene Place today, Lafayette was supposed to stay a little farther on, at the home of Polly Keen’s father, Colonel Abraham Bowman, whose farm lay along what is now Bowman Mill Road. Bad roads and weather made the Keen house the more practical stop, and Polly hosted him there. Bowman, a Revolutionary War veteran who had settled near Lexington in 1779, is also remembered as one of Lafayette’s hosts during the visit.

    The family story is about two households, and it leaves out everyone else on both farms. In 1810 the census counted 16 enslaved people in John Keen’s household. When census takers came to Abraham Bowman’s place in 1820, they counted 21; in 1830, five years after Lafayette’s visit, they counted 24, many of them children. Whoever cooked for Lafayette’s party that night, cared for its horses, and fed the escort camped on the lawn does not appear in the story the families handed down, or on the marker.

    What the Plaque Gets Wrong

    The problem is the phrase “…who had served as his Aide-De-Camp.” John Keen could not have served on Lafayette’s staff, or in the Revolution at all. His grave and the 1810 census put his birth around 1781, in Virginia, so he was a small child when the war ended. An aide-de-camp was a general’s personal staff officer, and Lafayette’s known aides were mostly French officers who came over with him or after him, such as Jean-Joseph Sourbader de Gimat, who led an assault at Yorktown. The earliest account of the visit does not make the claim either. The Kentucky Gazette’s report, printed three days later, calls his host simply “Mr. John Keen,” and describes Abraham Bowman, who rode beside Lafayette into town, as “an old fellow soldier.” As far as this research found, the “Major” and the aide-de-camp first appear on the plaque cast in 1936.

    1936 newspaper photo of four new historical marker plaques: First Newspaper, Jefferson Davis, Keeneland, and Iron Works Road
    The Keeneland plaque, lower left, before it was erected. Lexington Leader, May 8, 1936.

    The family connection to the Revolution runs instead through Abraham Bowman. He was colonel of the 8th Virginia Regiment and led it at Brandywine and at Germantown, then a village just north of Philadelphia, in 1777, and through the Battle of Monmouth, in New Jersey, in 1778. Lafayette fought at both Brandywine and Monmouth. Some modern accounts describe Bowman, not Keen, as Lafayette’s aide-de-camp, and others say only that he was a friend. His own biographers describe a regimental command, not service on Lafayette’s staff. It seems likely that a true story, an old soldier welcoming a commander he had served under, was simplified over time into the version cast in metal, with the son-in-law in the father-in-law’s place. That mix-up may be old. An 1896 application to the Sons of the American Revolution, filed four decades before the marker went up, already lists “John Keen,” husband of Mary Bowman, as a Revolutionary ancestor. The “Major” title is also unexplained; it may come from the militia, as many Kentucky titles did.

    The date on the plaque is off as well. Lafayette spent May 14 in Frankfort, at the dinner and ball given in his honor there. His night at the Keen house was the following one, Sunday, May 15, 1825.

    None of this changes what happened at the Keen house. Lafayette did spend a night with the Keens, and the family kept the memory of it for two centuries. The plaque simply asks the visit to carry more history than the records can confirm.

    Two Days in Lexington

    Lexington had about 6,000 residents in 1825 and had been preparing for weeks. Lafayette arrived on May 16 in the rain, and crowds lined the muddy road into town. Many of the men waiting for him were Revolutionary veterans, some of whom showed him the wounds they had received fighting at his side. One held up a right hand missing two fingers, shot away by a musket ball at Brandywine; he had been carried from the field, he said, at the same time as the wounded Lafayette.

    For roughly forty-eight hours he was hardly left alone. His quarters in town were at Mrs. Keen’s, a Lexington hotel kept by a Keen whose connection to John Keen is unclear. He was received at Transylvania University, then the leading college in the West, in the chapel of its main building at the head of what is now Gratz Park, where President Horace Holley spoke. He visited a girls’ school that renamed itself the Lafayette Female Academy in his honor; its building stood on North Upper Street. There was a military parade, a Masonic supper and ball for about 800 guests, and a dinner for about 1,400 people in a grove. On May 18 he headed north to Georgetown, and then on to Cincinnati and the east.

    A Formal Bow to Lewis Hayden

    Engraved portrait of Lewis Hayden, an older Black man with a gray beard, wearing a dark suit and bow tie
    Lewis Hayden (c. 1811–1889), later in life in Boston.

    Lafayette was the most famous critic of slavery to tour the United States in those years, and he spent much of the tour in slaveholding states as an honored guest of slaveholders. He had urged George Washington to free the people he enslaved, and in 1785 he bought a plantation in Cayenne, the French colony on the northeast coast of South America now called French Guiana, along with about seventy enslaved people, intending to educate them, pay them, and free them over time. The experiment ended after he fled the French Revolution in 1792 and was captured by Austrian forces, who kept him in Prussian and Austrian prisons for five years. The people on the plantation were sold that same year.

    In Lexington the contradiction showed in a small but meaningful moment. As his carriage passed through town on May 16, Lafayette bowed to a young enslaved boy named Lewis Hayden. Hayden never forgot it. He later escaped through the Underground Railroad, settled in Boston, and became one of that city’s leading abolitionists, sheltering people who had escaped slavery in his own house. He wrote that he dated his hatred of slavery from that day.

    From Keen Place to Keeneland

    The house where Lafayette slept was built in 1805, according to Keeneland, as the home of a branch of the Keen family; some accounts give a date around 1800. The spelling of the name drifted over the generations, and the final “e” became standard later. The family kept the land for nearly 150 years.

    Its best-known heir was John Oliver “Jack” Keene (1870–1943), a horse trainer who had worked in Chicago, California, Japan, and Russia, where in 1902 and 1903 he trained for Russian owners and won that country’s major races. Back in Kentucky, Keene began building a private racetrack on the family land in 1916: a one-and-one-sixteenth-mile course, a stone barn with living quarters, and an indoor training area modeled on what he had seen in Russia. He never had the money to finish it.

    When the Kentucky Association track, at the east end of Fifth Street in Lexington, closed in 1933, a group of horsemen led by Hal Price Headley looked for a new home for racing. On August 29, 1935, they bought 147 acres of Keene’s land for $130,000 and organized the Keeneland Association as a nonprofit. Keene’s unfinished barn became the clubhouse. Keeneland opened on October 15, 1936, before a crowd of about 8,000. It held its first horse auction in 1938, and its sales have since made it the largest Thoroughbred auction house in the world. In September 2026 its yearling sale alone brought in more than $536 million, the highest total ever recorded at a Thoroughbred auction. Keeneland was named a National Historic Landmark in 1986.

    Keeneland's grandstand rising above autumn trees, with white board fences in the foreground
    Keeneland’s grandstand, seen across the grounds.

    The old house stayed in the family until 1948. Keeneland bought it, with fifteen acres, in 2003 and reopened it as an event space in 2009 after a careful restoration. A small Keene family cemetery behind the house still belongs to the family; John Keen, who died in 1827, two years after Lafayette’s visit, is buried there. In May 2025, for the 200th anniversary of the visit, Keeneland held a reception at Keene Place.

    The Guest Before the Horses

    Most people who drive past Marker No. 2 are thinking about racing, and the plaque makes no effort to change that. It records a much older moment on the same ground: a tired, famous old man, a day out from Frankfort, stopping for the night at a farmhouse on a wet Sunday because the roads were bad. The details on the plaque may be off a bit, but the house he slept in is still standing a short walk from the paddock.

    A limestone gate pier and stone wall beside a tree-lined lane on the Keeneland grounds
    Stone wall and gate pier on the Keeneland grounds along Versailles Road.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Gazette, “Lafayette’s Visit” (May 19, 1825); Lexington Weekly Press (May 21, 1825); Lexington Herald (April 5, 1936); Lexington Leader (May 8, 1936); Kentucky Historical Society marker database and ExploreKYHistory entry for Keeneland (Marker No. 2); Kentucky Historical Society, “Marquis de Lafayette: ‘The Friend of Liberty’ and the Paradox of Slavery,” Kentucky Ancestors; Auguste Levasseur, Lafayette in America in 1824 and 1825 (1829); Ray E. Boomhower, “Swamped: The Marquis de Lafayette’s Indiana Adventure” (2020); Lexington Public Library, Lafayette’s Visit to Lexington walking tour; Northern Kentucky Tribune, “Kentucky’s Historical Marker Program One of Oldest, Largest in the United States”; Wikipedia, “Kentucky Association” and “Lafayette Land Grant”; “Local-Scale Turnpike Roads in Nineteenth-Century Kentucky,” Journal of Historical Geography; Wikipedia, “Visit of the Marquis de Lafayette to the United States”; Encyclopedia Virginia, “Abraham Bowman”; Daughters of the American Revolution, Honoring Our Patriots; U.S. Federal Census, Fayette County, Kentucky, 1810, 1820, and 1830; Find a Grave, John Keen(e) (1781–1827); will of Francis Keene, Kentucky Wills and Probate Records; Sons of the American Revolution membership applications index (1896); National Park Service, Colonial National Historical Park, biography of Jean-Joseph Sourbader de Gimat; Transylvania University Library, “Lafayette in Lexington”; Lafayette College Magazine, “In the Marquis’ Footsteps” (2019); Smiley Pete Publishing, “A Keene Interest in History” (2012); Keeneland Library, “Purchase of Keene Place, 2003”; National Register of Historic Places nomination, Keeneland Race Course; America’s Best Racing, “For Love of the Horse, For Generations to Come: A History of Keeneland Race Course” (2025); WUKY (May 15, 2025); Daily Racing Form (September 26, 2026); Sam Terry’s Kentucky, “Lafayette’s Visit to Versailles and Keene Place.”

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Front panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2110, African Cemetery No. 2, with a co-sponsor plaque below it, on a lawn beside the cemetery
    Reverse panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2110, African Cemetery No. 2, with headstones and trees behind it

    “Earliest recorded cemetery in Lexington to be organized, owned, and managed by African Americans. The site has been in existence since 1869. Trustees of Benevolent Society No. 2 successfully operated cemetery. Many individuals buried here were important leaders in the community.”

    “Buried here are leaders of: Ladies Auxiliary Society No. 2, Colored People’s Union Benevolent Society No. 1, Lexington A and M Fair of Colored People, Colored Orphan Industrial Home, the horse-racing industry, early public schools for African Americans, individuals for social and economic advancement after Civil War. Members of the U.S. Colored Troops buried here.”

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2110 — erected 2003

    419 E. Seventh St., Lexington | 38° 03′ 02″ N, 84° 28′ 41″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    The front of this marker is a statement of ownership. African Cemetery No. 2, it says, was the earliest recorded cemetery in Lexington “to be organized, owned, and managed by African Americans.” The reverse lists who is buried here, almost entirely by the organizations they built: benevolent societies, a fair, an orphans’ home, early schools, the horse industry, the United States Colored Troops. It does not name a single person.

    That fits the place more than it might seem. More than 5,000 people are believed to be buried on these eight acres. About 1,200 have been identified, and fewer than 600 graves have a stone. What the marker leaves out is how much work it took to keep this ground, and how often the city around it took pieces away.

    Wide lawn of African Cemetery No. 2 with scattered headstones, a flowering crepe myrtle, and mature trees under a blue sky
    African Cemetery No. 2, East Seventh Street.

    A Society Older Than Freedom

    The cemetery belonged to the Colored People’s Union Benevolent Society No. 2, usually shortened to Union Benevolent Society No. 2. It was chartered in 1852, thirteen years before the Thirteenth Amendment ended slavery in Kentucky, by founders including Lewis Page, Sam Breckinridge, and Leonard Fish. The cemetery’s National Register nomination describes its original members as enslaved men. The society’s purpose, in the Kentucky Historical Society’s summary, was to “take care of the sick, bury the dead, and perform other deeds of charity.” The cemetery itself would not come for another seventeen years.

    It worked the way most mutual aid societies of the period worked. Members paid dues, and in return the society looked after them when they were sick and buried them when they died. A member’s family received a coffin, a box, and a hearse, at a cost to the society of twenty dollars. Male members were expected to attend a brother’s funeral or pay a fifty-cent fine. At its peak the society had 685 members, the largest of Lexington’s Black fraternal organizations.

    Burial mattered because so little else was guaranteed. Before the war, Black Lexingtonians, enslaved and free, were buried where white institutions allowed, as in the old Presbyterian burying ground on Limestone Street. A society that could promise a decent funeral, paid for and attended by its own members, was offering something its members could not count on anywhere else.

    Eight Acres on Seventh Street

    On November 19, 1869, the society bought four acres on what is now East Seventh Street, then open land on the northeastern edge of town. The price was $1,500: $500 down and the rest over two years. Trustee Jordan C. Jackson, one of Lexington’s first Black professional funeral directors, negotiated the purchase. Four months later the Kentucky legislature chartered the cemetery, and the charter included a promise: the ground “shall never be used in any manner inconsistent with this act.”

    In 1875 the society bought four more acres next door, set aside for orphans, the poor, and the homeless of the Black community. In the 1880s the Ladies Auxiliary Society No. 2, the women’s organization named first on the back of the marker, added a narrow strip of land known as the Cemetery Ell, or Potter’s Field. By the end of the century a superintendent’s house stood near the entrance. A 1902 city directory lists John Carr as “Cemetery Superintendent.” The house showed that the ground was in active use, which helped discourage anyone hoping to build on it. It later burned, and the cemetery’s records were probably lost with it. That fire is one reason so many of the burials here are unidentified.

    Moved Here, and Moved Away

    Not everyone in the cemetery was buried here first. In 1889 the old Presbyterian cemetery on Limestone Street was sold for development, and roughly 300 bodies were dug up and moved to Seventh Street. According to the newspaper coverage at the time, many of the people who “strenuously opposed the removal” were Black. Among those moved were some of the most prominent free Black men of antebellum Lexington: Robert Cromwell (1780–1844), a founder of the Colored People’s Union Benevolent Society No. 1, the first organization named on the marker’s reverse; the merchant William Tucker; and George Tandy. No record survives of where in the cemetery their remains were placed.

    The most famous person ever buried here went the other way. Isaac Burns Murphy, born into slavery in 1861, became the first jockey to win the Kentucky Derby three times: 1884, 1890, and 1891. His winning percentage is still cited as one of the best in the sport’s history. When he died in February 1896, more than 500 people attended his funeral. He was buried at African Cemetery No. 2 in a grave with no stone, and over the following decades its exact location was forgotten.

    Isaac Murphy as a young man in satin jockey silks and a jockey cap, looking to his right
    Isaac Burns Murphy, about 1885. Library of Congress.

    In the 1960s a University of Kentucky publicist, Frank B. Borries Jr., spent three years trying to find it. In 1967, the Sunday Herald-Leader reported that Murphy’s remains had been removed “from an unmarked and neglected grave in the now abandoned old ‘No. 2 Cemetery’” and reburied beside the grave of Man o’ War. When the Kentucky Horse Park was built about a decade later, Murphy was moved again along with the horse, to the park entrance, where he remains today.

    Murphy is now probably the best-known Black horseman in Kentucky history. Many of the Black horsemen of his era are still here. Over many years, the late Dr. Anne Butler, a longtime member of the cemetery’s board, combed death certificates for occupations like jockey, trainer, groom, and hostler. The cemetery has since identified 159 men who worked in the racing industry. They include Oliver Lewis, who rode Aristides to victory in the first Kentucky Derby; James “Soup” Perkins, the second-youngest jockey ever to win the Derby, in 1895; the jockey Tommie Britton; Joseph Scott, a jockey who died at sixteen; and Cassius Clay Tankersly, who was killed in a race at Latonia and whose employer paid for his monument.

    Portrait of jockey Oliver Lewis
    Oliver Lewis. Wikimedia Commons.
    Engraving-style illustration of jockey James “Soup” Perkins in a cap and white scarf
    Illustration of James “Soup” Perkins, after a 1903 photograph.

    Railroads, Sewers, and Weeds

    The 1869 charter promised that the land would only ever be a cemetery. The city kept testing that promise. Around 1890 the Belt and Passenger Railroad laid track across the back of the property, cutting into the cemetery for nearly 744 feet and taking more than 19,000 square feet of ground. In 1934 the society’s acting president, Samuel Burdette, granted the city a strip of 7,376 square feet for a storm sewer. The deed specified that “no steam, gasoline or other mechanical shovel shall be used in excavating.” The construction damaged the grounds anyway.

    By then the society itself was fading. Burials remained steady through the 1930s, but the Union Benevolent Society No. 2 dissolved during the 1940s, and the cemetery was left with no one responsible for it. Burials continued even as the grass and brush grew over the graves. In the summer of 1963, residents and businessmen complained to the city that the overgrown cemetery was “a source of hay fever and a playground for the lawless,” and on August 21 city workers came out to clear the weeds.

    The city took control of the cemetery in 1973, with the last burial taking place in 1974. In 1979 a nonprofit, African Cemetery No. 2, Inc., formed to save it. With help from Mayor Jim Amato, volunteers spent 1979 and 1980 uncovering, resetting, and marking graves, and the brick pillars and iron fence along Seventh Street date from that effort. Vandalism and encroachment continued for years afterward, and the work of keeping the grounds has fallen mostly to volunteers ever since.

    Black iron fence along East Seventh Street, with headstones, a tall pine, and leafy trees behind it
    The iron fence along East Seventh Street, part of the 1979–80 restoration.

    Soldiers, Teachers, and a Voting Rights Martyr

    When the marker was dedicated in 2003, the Kentucky Historical Society counted 43 known soldiers of the United States Colored Troops buried here, including one member of the 54th Massachusetts, the regiment later made famous by the film Glory. Research since then has raised the count of Civil War soldiers to 112, about 80 of whom trained at Camp Nelson in Jessamine County, where about 10,000 of Kentucky’s roughly 24,000 Black soldiers enlisted and trained. Altogether, 148 veterans have been identified, including a dozen Buffalo Soldiers from the era of the Spanish-American War, 18 veterans of World War I, and four of World War II.

    One of the Buffalo Soldiers is John Bell, a private in the 9th U.S. Cavalry who died on October 14, 1927. His government-issue headstone stands beside an interpretive sign about the Buffalo Soldiers. “Buffalo Soldiers” refers to the Black regulars of the 9th and 10th Cavalry and the 24th and 25th Infantry, regiments the Army created after the Civil War. The name is usually credited to the Plains nations they were sent to fight. For decades they fought and policed Native nations in the West on behalf of a government that did little to protect their own rights back home. In 1898 the 9th and 10th Cavalry fought in Cuba during the Spanish-American War, including in the assault on the San Juan Heights. According to the cemetery’s sign, most of the Buffalo Soldiers buried here were recruited in Central Kentucky for that war.

    Weathered government-issue headstone for John Bell, 9th U.S. Cavalry, beside a white sign titled Buffalo Soldiers
    John Bell’s headstone and the cemetery’s Buffalo Soldiers sign.

    One of the World War I veterans is Clarence Espy, a Lexington native who served with the 369th Infantry, the “Harlem Hellfighters.” The 369th spent more time in front-line combat than any other American regiment of the war, and France awarded the regiment as a whole the Croix de Guerre, a French military decoration for bravery in combat.

    Black soldiers of the 369th Infantry in uniform, seated and standing in two rows
    Men of the 369th Infantry awarded the Croix de Guerre, 1919. National Archives.

    The cemetery also holds J. H. Jackson, the first president of the State Normal School for Colored Persons in Frankfort, now Kentucky State University, and Claiborne Lee, whose stone records that he lived to the age of 111. It holds the leaders of the Colored A&M Fair and the Colored Orphan Industrial Home, both of which have Kentucky Historical Society markers of their own.

    Portrait of J. H. Jackson, a bearded man in a dark suit
    J. H. Jackson, 1897. From Biographical Sketches of Prominent Negro Men and Women of Kentucky.

    And it holds Robert Charles O’Hara Benjamin. Benjamin was a lawyer, a journalist, and the editor of the Lexington Standard, a Black weekly he had bought in 1897. On October 2, 1900, he was helping Black men in Lexington register to vote when a white man named Michael Moynahan harassed the group. Benjamin confronted him, and Moynahan beat him with a revolver. Moynahan was arrested for assault and released the same day. That evening he waited outside Benjamin’s house and, when Benjamin turned to run, shot him in the back six times. Moynahan claimed self-defense, and the case was dismissed. A monument was raised over Benjamin’s grave in 1910. In June 2026, as part of the city’s Juneteenth events, Lexington dedicated a marker in his honor, its first with the Equal Justice Initiative, the Montgomery, Alabama, nonprofit that documents victims of racial violence and created the National Memorial for Peace and Justice.

    Engraving-style illustration of R. C. O. Benjamin, a man with a mustache in a dark suit and tie
    Illustration of R. C. O. Benjamin, after an 1891 engraving.

    The Cemetery Today

    African Cemetery No. 2 sits in a residential neighborhood, behind an iron fence on East Seventh Street. Inside, two grass paths run from the street back toward the rail line, between rows of headstones of every size and age, from tall obelisks to small, weathered blocks with nothing legible left on them. Crepe myrtles line the paths, and mature oaks shade the edges. White interpretive panels, made by University of Kentucky students through a Young Equestrian Scholars program begun in 2010, mark the graves of individual horsemen. In 2015 a memorial bench and signage were placed at the original grave site of Isaac Murphy and his wife, Lucy. Much of the grass is open lawn, but given how many burials were never marked, it is unlikely that much of it is empty.

    Rows of headstones on a sloping lawn at African Cemetery No. 2, with white interpretive panels and a large flowering crepe myrtle
    Grass paths and interpretive panels at African Cemetery No. 2.

    The marker was dedicated on June 19, 2003, Juneteenth, and the date has stuck. Since 2005 the cemetery has held a Juneteenth Jubilee each year, placing an American flag on the grave of every Civil War soldier and reading each name aloud. The cemetery was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2004.

    The 1869 charter said this land would never be used for anything but burial. The railroad took a strip of it, the sewer took another, and Isaac Murphy was moved out entirely. Even so, the remaining eight acres on Seventh Street are still a cemetery.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker inscription and ExploreKYHistory entry for African Cemetery No. 2 (No. 2110); National Register of Historic Places nomination, Cemetery of the Union Benevolent Society No. 2 (2004); University of Kentucky African Cemetery No. 2 project (history, walking tour, and newspaper references, including the Sunday Herald-Leader, April 30, 1967); African Cemetery No. 2, Inc., “Lexington’s African American Horsemen: Findings and Recognition” and World War I veterans list; The Cultural Landscape Foundation; Kentucky Photo Archive (Lexington Herald-Leader, August 21, 1963); Kentucky Horse Park; FOX 56 News (June 2026); Wikipedia entries for African Cemetery No. 2, Isaac Burns Murphy, Oliver Lewis, and R. C. O. Benjamin. Images: Library of Congress; National Archives; Wikimedia Commons; William D. Johnson, Biographical Sketches of Prominent Negro Men and Women of Kentucky (1897).

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • “Under Vine Street flows the Town Branch of Elkhorn, the stream upon whose banks Lexington was established in 1779. Used in the early days to bring merchandise to Lexington from Ohio River. On Town Branch was launched Edward West’s steamboat in 1793. Heavy floods troubled Lexington until a large underground channel built in 1930s.”

    Presented by Lexington-Fayette Co. Historic Commission
    The Town Branch historical marker beside a downtown Lexington street, with Vine Street and US 25 and US 421 signs and a skywalk behind it

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 1556 — erected 1976

    West Main St., Central Bank Center parking lot, Lexington | 38° 03′ 00″ N, 84° 30′ 05″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    Most people who pass this marker are walking to a game at Rupp Arena or a concert or to a convention, and few of them give a thought to waterways. There are none in sight. Yet the marker is about a creek, and the creek is still here, flowing in the dark beneath the pavement a short distance away. It is the reason Lexington sits where it does. It also gave the young town water power, a sewer, epidemics, and floods. Then Lexington spent a century and a half covering it up.

    The marker packs a great deal into four sentences, and two of them need a closer look. But the larger story, of a town that grew up around a stream and then buried it, is better than anything on the plaque.

    A Town Built on a Creek

    Town Branch begins at springs on the east side of Lexington and runs west and northwest through the city, joining South Elkhorn Creek near the Woodford County line. From there its water travels by way of Elkhorn Creek and the Kentucky River to the Ohio.

    In June 1775, a party of hunters camped at a spring west of here. When they heard news of the fighting at Lexington, Massachusetts, they named the place after it. Nobody settled until April 1779, when Robert Patterson and a party of men from Harrodsburg built a blockhouse near the creek, close to where Main and Mill streets meet today. The availability of water decided the location. A fort needed a reliable supply, and the branch and its springs provided one.

    When the town was laid out, the creek ran through a strip of public land called the Commons, open to everyone for water, washing, and livestock. In 1790 the town trustees decided to dig a straight canal to carry the branch through the center of town, with locust trees planted along each side. In 1797 they ordered it straightened again and widened to sixteen feet. The street along it became Water Street. In other words, Lexington began engineering its creek almost as soon as it had one.

    The branch soon went to work. John Cocke built a grist mill on it in 1788, often called the first water mill in Kentucky. Tanyards (where animal hides were soaked and cured into leather), a hat factory, woolen and paper mills, ropewalks, a brewery, and distilleries followed. Elijah Culpepper is said to have run a still beside the creek as early as 1780. West of town, the mill village of Manchester grew up along the banks after 1805. It later became the center of Lexington’s distilling industry, and it came to be known as Irishtown for the immigrants who worked in its mills and on the railroad. Much of the hemp that made early Lexington rich was spun and woven into rope and bagging by enslaved people in factories near the creek.

    Merchandise from the Ohio River?

    The marker says the creek was “used in the early days to bring merchandise to Lexington from Ohio River.” This is the claim that holds up least well.

    Town Branch was never navigable in any practical sense. A history prepared for Gatton Park describes it as “hardly big enough to float a canoe” except in flood. Even then, water flows downhill, away from Lexington and toward the Ohio. Nothing heavy came upstream.

    Goods reached early Lexington the hard way. Merchants bought their stock in Philadelphia or Baltimore and had it hauled over the mountains to Pittsburgh. From there it went by flatboat down the Ohio to Limestone, now Maysville, the river landing that served as central Kentucky’s front door, and then by wagon about sixty miles south to Lexington. Outbound trade ran in reverse: hemp, tobacco, flour, and whiskey went by wagon to landings on the Kentucky River or to the Ohio, then by flatboat to New Orleans. Lexington’s lack of a usable waterway was one of its biggest economic handicaps. It is a large part of why Louisville and Cincinnati, sitting on the Ohio, overtook it after steamboats began running upriver in the 1810s. The Lexington and Ohio Railroad, chartered in 1830, was meant to solve the problem by laying track all the way to the Ohio at Louisville. It reached Frankfort in 1834, but the line never made it to the river.

    It is possible that the marker’s writers had in mind the creek’s connection by water to the Ohio, or the occasional small boat floated down it in high water. But as a description of how merchandise came to Lexington, the marker gets it wrong.

    Edward West’s Steamboat

    The marker’s next claim, that “on Town Branch was launched Edward West’s steamboat in 1793,” is true in a narrower sense than it sounds.

    Engraving-style portrait of an older man with swept-back hair, wearing a high-collared coat and cravat
    Illustration of Edward West (1757–1827).

    Edward West was a real and remarkable Lexington craftsman. Born in Virginia in 1757, he worked in Lexington as a silversmith, clock and watchmaker, and gunsmith, and he was a tinkerer of the first order. His son, William Edward West, became a well-known portrait painter.

    The source for the 1793 date is Robert Peter’s History of Fayette County, published in 1882, almost ninety years after the event. Peter wrote that West tested a steam-driven boat on the town fork of Elkhorn, which had to be dammed to give it enough water to float. He believed this was “in all reasonable probability” the first steamboat ever invented. The best description of the boat itself comes from Thomas Barlow, a Lexington inventor who knew West. Barlow said the engine had a two-inch cylinder, and that “the boat was not big enough for a man to get in.” In other words, West’s boat was a small working prototype, not a vessel anyone could ride.

    That does not make it unimportant. West received a federal patent for a steam engine on July 6, 1802, along with patents for a gun lock (the firing mechanism of a musket or rifle) and a nail-cutting machine. The patent models were later destroyed in a fire at the Patent Office, but a model of his steam engine survives in the collections of the Kentucky Historical Society. In 1816, according to a history of West’s career, a steamboat built on his plan left Hickman Creek in Jessamine County bound for New Orleans. It never came back.

    Engraving-style illustration of the steamboat Clermont, with a tall smokestack, an exposed engine with a walking beam and flywheels, and an American flag at each end
    Illustration of Robert Fulton’s steamboat Clermont, 1807.

    The larger claim, that Lexington invented the steamboat, needs care. John Fitch was running steamboats on the Delaware River in 1787 and 1790, well before 1793, and James Rumsey demonstrated one on the Potomac in 1787. Robert Fulton’s Clermont, the first commercially successful American steamboat, came in 1807. West belongs among the many inventors working on the same problem in those years. What sets him apart is where he did it: in a landlocked town, on a creek that had to be dammed to float a prototype. West made his money from the nail machine. He died in Lexington in 1827.

    An Open Sewer

    As Lexington grew, the creek that gave it life became its drain. Privies, stables, slaughterhouses, tanneries, and distilleries all emptied into the branch, and so did the streets every time it rained. There was no treatment of any kind. Through the nineteenth century the town covered the stream piece by piece. Sections were arched over with brick and stone, and buildings, a market house, and railroad warehouses were built directly on top. By the 1890s, maps show almost no open water downtown.

    Covering the creek did not clean it. In the summer of 1833, Asiatic cholera reached Lexington and killed about 500 people in a few weeks, out of a population of around 6,000. A second epidemic in 1849 killed more than 300. Doctors of the time did not know that cholera spreads through contaminated water, but the town’s wells and its creek were part of the same polluted ground. Burial grounds overflowed, one reason the Lexington Cemetery was established in 1849, a story told in the Lexington Cemetery article.

    Newspapers in the 1880s and 1890s regularly denounced the condition of the branch. A sanitary sewer system finally arrived in 1918. But the old creek channel was still carrying both storm water and sewage, and it was too small for either.

    The Floods and the 1930s Channel

    The marker is right that floods troubled Lexington. On July 7, 1923, a summer cloudburst left a foot of water at Main and Broadway, and one newspaper columnist quipped, “So this is Venice!” On June 28 and 29, 1928, more than five inches of rain turned Main Street into a river three feet deep. The Herald called it “the most disastrous flood in the history of this section,” and estimates of the damage ran into the millions. On August 1 and 2, 1932, seven and a half inches fell in seven hours. Losses in the city topped a million dollars, and out in the county six people drowned when Hickman Creek swept a house off its foundation.

    Engraving-style view of a flooded street lined with trees, with a brick warehouse at left and people wading in the distance
    Illustration of a flooded Lexington street, 1928.

    The underground channel the marker mentions came out of the Great Depression. Work on a new Town Branch channel began under the Civil Works Administration, a short-lived federal jobs program, in the winter of 1933 to 1934. It stopped when that program ended. On May 4, 1934, the Lexington Herald reported that the federal government had authorized “a resumption of the work on the Town Branch channel.” Construction of a large brick barrel vault resumed that month, and over 1934 and 1935, federal relief money paid to separate storm sewers from sanitary sewers and to build a much larger culvert through the Vine Street corridor.

    One more episode from that same spring shows just how much the buried creek still carried. On Saturday, April 28, 1934, a fire broke out at the James E. Pepper Distillery on Manchester Street, beside the creek west of downtown, and thousands of gallons of whiskey poured into Town Branch. Four days later, an Associated Press story reported that every fish in Elkhorn Creek near Weisenberger’s Mill in Woodford County was drunk. The fish were floating at the surface, “very much alive but in a stupor,” and local people were scooping them up by the bagful with rakes and pitchforks. Weisenberger Mill, owned by the same family since 1865, still grinds flour and meal there today.

    Bird's-eye view of a large distillery complex with brick warehouses, a railroad line, and horse-drawn wagons on the street
    Bird’s-eye view of the Jas. E. Pepper & Co. distillery, undated. Source: Visit Lexington.

    The new channel ended the worst of the downtown flooding. It did not end the creek’s troubles. Combined and leaking sewers kept fouling Town Branch for decades, and in recent years a federal consent decree with the Environmental Protection Agency has required Lexington to spend hundreds of millions of dollars rebuilding its sewer system, work that is still being finished.

    Under Vine Street, and Back into the Light

    The railroad tracks that once ran along the old Water Street corridor were later removed, and the wide street built in their place is today’s Vine Street. That is why the marker can say, accurately, that the creek flows “under Vine Street.” The marker itself, though, does not stand on Vine. It sits a block south on West Main, at the edge of the arena parking lot, close to where the buried creek passes beneath the Rupp Arena and convention center complex. The Mary Todd Lincoln House stands a block to the west.

    Downstream, the creek’s banks were home to working neighborhoods that the rest of the city often overlooked. Davis Bottom, south of the creek along the railroad, grew after the Civil War when a landowner sold lots to Black families, and it became a mixed-race neighborhood of factory and rail workers living in a low, flood-prone hollow. Much of it was cleared in the early 2000s for the Newtown Pike extension, now Oliver Lewis Way.

    In the last few years, after a century and a half of burying Town Branch, Lexington has started to bring it back. The Town Branch Commons trail, a linear park through downtown along the creek’s route, opened in 2022. On August 23, 2025, Gatton Park on the Town Branch opened behind Rupp Arena on what had been a parking lot. There, the creek leaves its culvert and runs in the open again for the first time in generations. During construction, workers found a stone wall dating to around 1790, from the trustees’ first attempts to tame the stream. They took it apart stone by stone and rebuilt it beside the new channel.

    So the marker’s first sentence is still the truest one. Lexington was established on the banks of this stream. For most of its history, the town worked hard to forget that. Now, a few hundred feet from this marker, you can stand on a bank and watch it flow again.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker database, Marker No. 1556; Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org), entry 58557; Gatton Park on the Town Branch, “Town Branch: History of the Creek” (2025); “The Disappearance of Town Branch,” University of Kentucky geography paper (2001); Margaret M. Bridwell, “Edward West, Silversmith and Inventor,” Filson Club History Quarterly (1947); Robert Peter, History of Fayette County, Kentucky (1882); Smiley Pete Publishing, “A Creek Runs under It” (2012); The Lexington Times, “‘So This Is Venice!’” (2026); WKYT, “How the Town Branch Impacted Lexington’s History” (2025); WEKU, “Gatton Park on Town Branch” (2025); The Lexington Herald, May 4, 1934; The Courier-Journal (Associated Press), May 3, 1934.

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Listen to this story

    Narration is AI-generated from the text of this article.

    Front panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2460, Florence Crittenton Home, beside a brick gatepost and iron fence on West Fourth Street in Lexington
    Reverse panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2460, Florence Crittenton Home, on a lawn along West Fourth Street

    “In 1894, a group of local women established the House of Mercy on this site to provide a home for single pregnant women. In 1921 the home became affiliated with Florence Crittenton Homes, founded by Charles Crittenton in memory of his daughter, Florence, for the purpose of helping women in need.”

    “For 118 years, the Florence Crittenton Home helped countless women and girls. Essential social & medical services were provided, with aid from staff, donors, volunteers, schools, churches, hospitals, and government funding. The home closed in 2013.”

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2460 — erected 2015

    519 W. Fourth St., Lexington | 38° 03′ 26″ N, 84° 29′ 50″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    At the bottom of both panels, in small italic letters, is a line most people walk past: “Dedicated to former residents, their babies, and caregivers.” It is the only place on the marker where the babies appear. The main text speaks of “help” and “services,” and of women and girls in need. It does not say what happened to the children born to the young women who lived here, or how they came to live here in the first place.

    That is not unusual for a historical marker, and it is not a mark against the home. For most of its history, the work done at 519 West Fourth Street was something families did not discuss. But the story behind the marker is larger than its two panels. It includes a grieving father in New York, a founding mission the marker leaves out, and a quiet shift in what “help” meant.

    A Daughter Named Florence

    Charles Nelson Crittenton made his fortune in medicine. In 1861 he opened a wholesale drug business in New York City with about $60. By the time it incorporated in 1893, the company was valued at $800,000.

    In March 1882 his four-year-old daughter, Florence, died of scarlet fever. Her death changed the direction of his life. Crittenton turned to religion and to what nineteenth-century reformers called rescue work, and nearly everything he built afterward carried his daughter’s name. In 1883 he opened the Florence Night Mission on Bleecker Street in Manhattan, a shelter for prostitutes and other women the era described as “fallen.”

    For most of the rest of his life, Crittenton was on the road. He traveled the country as an evangelist, at one point touring with other preachers aboard a train he called the “Special News Extra,” and later living and working out of his own railroad “Gospel Car,” preaching especially to prostitutes and unwed mothers. In 1893, in Atlanta, he met Kate Waller Barrett, and the two built the mission into a national organization, chartered by Congress in 1898. More than 70 homes had opened by the time Crittenton died in San Francisco in November 1909.

    Engraving-style portrait of Charles N. Crittenton, a heavyset man with a large mustache, wearing a dark suit and a white bow tie
    Charles Nelson Crittenton (1833–1909). Illustration based on a period portrait.

    Barrett told the story herself when she came to Lexington years later. “There have been many fantastic tales circulated as to what was the cause of the starting of the Florence Crittenton Homes,” she told the Lexington Herald in 1921, “but the real cause was this.” A four-year-old girl had died, and every home in the chain had grown out of the single one her father started “as a memorial to his baby daughter.”

    Barrett, who led the organization after his death, had firm views about mothers and children. The Crittenton homes generally opposed separating a mother from her baby for adoption except in extreme cases. Motherhood, in Barrett’s view, was part of a woman’s reform, not an obstacle to it. “Our girls need the influence of child-life upon them,” she wrote.

    The House of Mercy

    Newspaper headline reading “The House of Mercy: Weekly meetings of the good women who are organizing and directing this great Christian enterprise, examining into the management of rescue homes in other cities”
    Kentucky Leader, November 5, 1894.

    Lexington’s home began separately, and not as a maternity home. In the fall of 1894 a group of local women began meeting every Wednesday morning at the home of Mrs. John Pew to organize what they called a “rescue home.” The Kentucky Leader described their purpose in the language of the day: Lexington’s “outlying suburbs are reeking with sin and with misery, the fruit of sin,” while churches sent their dollars overseas and ignored “a great missionary field” at their own doors.

    The women did their homework, visiting rescue homes in New York, among them a Florence Crittenton home, and in Louisville. Their plan was practical as well as religious. Residents would learn cooking, laundry, dressmaking, and embroidery, so that when they left they would “have a way of making a competency.” The doors would be open to any woman who knocked while there was a room and a bed. “Those who have children and those who have none will be equally welcome,” the paper reported. “No questions will be asked.”

    In January 1895 the Leader announced that “Lexington’s House of Mercy for Fallen Women” would open the following week in “the old Totten place on Fourth street,” which had been rented and furnished. The eighteen-room house, the paper predicted, would be full almost from opening day. According to the 1980 National Register nomination, the city and the county each contributed $3,000 toward the effort, and a public subscription raised another $1,000.

    Within weeks the board had to correct a misunderstanding. A newspaper report had said the House of Mercy would take in children from Megowan Street, the heart of Lexington’s red-light district. Not so, the board replied: the House of Mercy “is strictly for erring women who wish to reform.” The statement listed the seven women who ran the home: Annie W. Bain, Martha R. Stockwell, Mary Hamilton, Mollie Tilford Wood, Fanny A. Pew, Fanny B. Threlkeld, and Martha McChesney.

    This is the first place the marker needs a closer look. It says the House of Mercy was founded “to provide a home for single pregnant women.” That describes what the home became, not what it was. In 1894 the founders set out to rescue women from prostitution and what they called lives of sin. Pregnant women were surely among those who came, but maternity care became the home’s focus only later.

    Joining the Crittenton Chain

    Engraving-style portrait of Kate Waller Barrett, an older woman in a feathered hat, with a cross and medals at her collar
    Kate Waller Barrett (1857–1925). Illustration based on a photograph in the Library of Congress.

    By 1921 the House of Mercy had operated for, in the Herald’s words, “practically 27 years of unvarying success in its particular field,” although the work had been carried on “without any ostentation and often in spite of adverse criticism.” That February, Kate Waller Barrett, by then president of the National Florence Crittenton Mission, came to Lexington at the invitation of the home’s officers. The founders had studied the Crittenton model in New York in 1894. Twenty-seven years later, their home joined it.

    The home’s president, Miss Sue B. Scott, announced the change. The House of Mercy would take the Crittenton name and join a chain of 78 homes, keeping its property and its local board. Until then it had run a single department, its rescue work. Under the Crittenton plan it would add two more, one working with the Public Health Nursing Service and one with a detention home. And it would no longer be strictly local: “Girls from all parts of the state will be accepted,” the Herald reported, with the counties that sent them expected to pay for their stay.

    Barrett explained why. In the Catlettsburg jail, she said, twenty girls were being held, “quarantined by the Public Health Service,” and something would have to be done for them after their release if they were to be kept from “slipping back into the same life they had been leading.” During and after World War I, federal and state authorities detained thousands of women suspected of carrying venereal disease, often in local jails, in an effort historians now call the American Plan. In 1921, part of the Lexington home’s new mission was to receive some of those women.

    A House Older Than It Looks, and Younger Than Some Say

    Two-story red brick house with white-trimmed windows and a small columned front porch, with a later brick wing to one side, set back behind a wide lawn
    The George W. Grant House at 519 W. Fourth St., home of the House of Mercy and the Florence Crittenton Home from 1895 to 2013.

    The building the House of Mercy moved into was already old by Lexington standards, and its first owner has a story of his own. In 1947, when the home held an open house, the Lexington Leader asked local historian C. Frank Dunn about it. Thomas Grant and Francis Downing, Dunn said, had been partners in a large store on West Short Street that sold drugs, groceries, and paint. Together they bought the Fourth Street tract from Mary C. Russell, daughter of Col. John Todd, who was killed at the Battle of Blue Licks in 1782. Grant later bought out his partner’s share and built a house for his son, George W. Grant. It was the first house on Fourth Street west of Limestone, at a time when that stretch was still outside the town limits.

    Dunn also connected Grant to an earlier act of charity. Grant had taken in a Lexington boy named John Grimes as an apprentice, and Grimes became almost a member of the family. He went on to study under the portrait painter Matthew Jouett and became a respected artist himself, working in Philadelphia, Nashville, and Louisville before he died of tuberculosis in 1837, at 38. The man who gave one homeless child a home, the paper observed, had “unwittingly” built a house that would one day become “a refuge for girls in need of help.”

    Oil portrait of John Grimes as a young man, with dark curly hair, a white cravat, and a dark high-collared coat
    John Grimes, by Matthew Harris Jouett, about 1824. The Metropolitan Museum of Art.

    Dunn dated the house to 1823, and that date still circulates. The National Register nomination, written in 1980, is more cautious. Grant and Downing bought the land in 1823, it agrees, but the house itself, a two-story, five-bay brick building with a central hall, looks more like the work of the late 1840s or 1850s. George W. Grant likely died there in 1863.

    Later owners added Italianate trim, and by 1890 the place was known as “the old Totten home,” after Alfred I. Totten and his sisters. The front porch dates to the mid-1890s, about the time the House of Mercy arrived, and a twentieth-century wing was added as the home grew. The property was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1980 as the George W. Grant House.

    The setting suited the home’s purpose, because privacy was part of what it offered. Fourth Street west of Limestone was at the edge of town, and it never became a fashionable address. By 1980 the house stood between a tobacco warehouse and an industrial building, with a rail line at the corner of the lot, yet the nomination noted that it was “approached inconspicuously,” screened by mature trees and a circular drive. For women leaving the street in 1895, and for the pregnant girls of later decades whose families wanted no one to know, that discretion was part of the service.

    To Keep a Baby, or Give It Up

    What “help” meant changed over the twentieth century, and that change is the part of the story the marker leaves out.

    Barrett’s policy of keeping mothers and babies together did not last. As states rewrote adoption laws and the community funds that paid for charities pushed homes toward professional social work, the old Crittenton approach came to look outdated. A national Crittenton conference in 1943 called for closer work with adoption agencies.

    In the decades after World War II, maternity homes across the country became places where unmarried pregnant girls were sent to wait out their pregnancies away from home, give birth, and, very often, surrender their babies. Historians sometimes call the period from 1945 to 1973 the Baby Scoop Era. One widely cited estimate puts the number of infants surrendered by unmarried mothers in those years at about 1.5 million.

    Lexington’s home followed the same path, and in 1959 it described its work plainly. A Lexington Herald feature that October called the home “more than a ‘shelter’ for unwed mothers.” It had room for nineteen girls and had helped sixty-four the year before. They came from Lexington, from across Kentucky, and from other states, paying on a sliding scale of $175 for Fayette County residents, $225 for other Kentuckians, and $275 for those from out of state, though no one was turned away for inability to pay. Married girls were not accepted. Two social workers from the state’s Division of Children’s Services visited each week, and the home made “arrangements with the girls who wish to place their babies for adoption, as most do.” The decision, the article said, was left “strictly to the mothers themselves.”

    There is no reason to doubt that the home believed that. But the same article shows how the system was built: girls sent away from home for months, a state adoption agency on the premises every week, and an outcome that most residents arrived at. Former residents of maternity homes elsewhere have described how little room that left for another choice. The home reported holding its records back to the late 1890s, and an adoption reunion registry listed it as a contact for adoptees and birth mothers looking for one another. The small italic line on the marker, which names “their babies” separately from the residents, may be the closest any public text in Lexington comes to acknowledging that many of those mothers and children were separated.

    From Maternity Home to Treatment Center

    After 1973, as unmarried motherhood became more accepted, maternity homes nationwide closed or changed. By 1980 the Lexington home still served single pregnant women, but most of its money now came from federal sources. The “government funding” on the marker’s reverse was not a footnote. Public money had been part of the home since the city and county helped open it.

    In its final decades the home became a residential treatment center for girls and young women who had been abused, neglected, or abandoned, and for pregnant and parenting teenagers with behavioral or mental health needs.

    That dependence on public money is what ended it. In November 2013 the home announced it would close, saying it no longer had the money to operate and that the state was no longer referring girls to it.

    Dedicated to Former Residents

    The Kentucky Historical Society dedicated the marker on May 9, 2015, about eighteen months after the home closed. By then the property already had a new life. In 2014 Providence Montessori School, which had started in 1965 at St. Peter Claver Church a block away on Fourth Street, opened its middle school campus in the old house, with gardens, fruit trees, and space for students to raise chickens and keep bees on the two-and-a-half-acre grounds.

    Montessori is not a single organization but a method of education, developed in the early twentieth century by the Italian physician Maria Montessori and used today by thousands of independent schools. Providence is one of them, a parent-owned school. Its middle school follows Montessori’s idea of the Erdkinder, German for “children of the earth.” In the 1930s she proposed that adolescents learn best on the land, doing real work such as farming and running a small business, as a step toward adult independence.

    It is a fitting second use for a building that spent more than a century housing teenagers. But the marker’s dedication line is worth reading twice. Over 118 years, a great many women and girls lived here. Some of them kept their children. Many, especially in the middle decades of the century, likely did not, and some of those mothers and children may still be looking for one another. The marker does not tell their stories. It does, in its smallest type, make room for them.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker database, Marker No. 2460; Kentucky Leader (Lexington), November 5, 1894, January 16, 1895, and March 2, 1895; Lexington Herald, February 25, 1921, and October 6, 1959; Lexington Leader, October 25, 1947; National Register of Historic Places Inventory–Nomination Form, George W. Grant House / Lexington House of Mercy / Florence Crittenton Home of Lexington (1980); Kentucky Photo Archive (Lexington Herald-Leader), “Florence Crittenton Home, 1947”; Virginia Commonwealth University Social Welfare History Project, “Florence Crittenton Homes: A History” and “Crittenton, Charles Nelson”; Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org), entry 169840; WMKY, “Florence Crittenton Site to Receive Historical Marker” (2015); WTVQ, “Florence Crittendon Home in Lexington to Shut Down This Month” (2013); GuideStar, Florence Crittenton Home & Services Inc. profile; Lexington Family Magazine, “Providence Montessori Will Open New Middle School at Historic Site” (2014); Providence Montessori School, “Facilities”; Wikipedia, “Charles Nelson Crittenton” and “Erdkinder”; Florence Crittenton Home Reunion Registry.

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • “Election day, Aug. 6, 1855, known as Bloody Monday due to riots led by ‘Know-Nothing’ mobs. This political party was anti-Catholic and nativist. Attacks on German immigrants east of downtown and Irish in the west caused at least 22 deaths, arson, and looting. Catholic Cathedral of the Assumption & St. Martin’s Church were threatened with destruction.”

    “This party feared that Catholic immigrants from Germany and Ireland threatened Protestantism and democracy. By 1854, the party claimed a million members nationwide and led Jefferson Co. govt. They split over slavery and by the end of the Civil War they had vanished from politics in Louisville and Jefferson Co. Given by Anc. Ord. Hibernians & German-Amer. Club.”

    Front panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2205, “Bloody Monday,” on West Main Street in Louisville
    Reverse panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2205, “American (Know-Nothing) Party,” in Louisville

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2205 — erected 2006

    1011 W. Main St., Louisville | 38° 15′ 28″ N, 85° 46′ 01″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    The marker stands at the curb on West Main Street, in front of the Kentucky Lottery’s headquarters, a few blocks west of the bourbon distilleries and museums that draw visitors downtown. Across the street is a costume supply store. Nothing on the block suggests what happened here in August 1855. This stretch of Main between Tenth and Eleventh Streets was lined with frame houses rented mostly to Irish families. By the night of the August 6 election for governor and Congress, those houses were burning, and people trying to escape them were being shot.

    The marker covers the riot on one side and the political party behind it on the other. Both panels are accurate in outline. The fuller story is worth telling, along with a few places where the marker’s wording smooths over something more complicated.

    A City Divided by Birthplace

    Louisville in the early 1850s was one of the fastest-growing cities in the West, and much of that growth came from Europe. Irish families fleeing the famine and Germans leaving the upheavals that followed the revolutions of 1848 arrived by the thousands. Louisville had about 43,000 residents at the 1850 census, and by the time of the riot, roughly a third of the city’s people were immigrants. They settled in distinct neighborhoods, as the marker notes: Germans east of downtown, around Shelby Street and in what is now Butchertown and Phoenix Hill, and the Irish to the west, along the river and Main Street. Most were Catholic, and most of those who could vote voted Democratic.

    The “Know-Nothings” grew out of that immense change. The movement began in the early 1850s as a network of secret lodges, formally called the Order of the Star Spangled Banner, whose members were instructed to answer questions about it by saying they knew nothing. As the Whig Party collapsed, the order went public as the American Party and drew many former Whigs. Its program was straightforward: keep Catholics and the foreign-born out of office, and lengthen the waiting period before immigrants could become citizens and vote.

    Nineteenth-century photographic portrait of John Barbee, Know-Nothing mayor of Louisville
    John Barbee (1815–1888). Courtesy of the Pewee Valley Historical Society.

    In Louisville, the party moved fast. In April 1855, John Barbee won the mayor’s race on the Know-Nothing ticket, and within weeks the party controlled city government. The outgoing mayor, James Stephens Speed, a convert to Catholicism, had already been pushed aside by a court ruling over the election. Rumors spread that weapons were being stored in Catholic churches, and in the weeks before the August vote, nativist crowds searched at least one of them. They found nothing.

    George D. Prentice and the Louisville Journal

    Much of the city’s political temperature was set by George D. Prentice (1802–1870), the Connecticut-born editor of the Louisville Journal. Prentice had founded the paper in 1830 to support Henry Clay, and his sharp, satirical pen made it one of the most widely quoted papers in the country. After Clay’s death in 1852 and the collapse of the Whigs, Prentice brought his readers with him into the Know-Nothing camp.

    Masthead of the Louisville Daily Journal dated Monday, August 6, 1855
    Louisville Daily Journal, August 6, 1855. Kentucky Digital Newspaper Program, University of Kentucky Libraries.

    In the days before the election, the Journal called the pope “an inflated Italian despot” and warned of the “overweening and most pestilent influence of the foreign swarms.” On the morning of the vote, the paper ran a column of short rallying items. One told readers to “whip the foreigners as Washington did at Yorktown.” Another read: “Americans, are you all ready? We think we hear you shout ‘Ready!’ Well, fire! and may heaven have mercy on the foe.” On the editorial page, responding to word that German voters meant to go to the polls, the paper warned that “if a collision be provoked by them, it will occur. And, if it do occur, there is but one way in which it can possibly terminate.”

    Engraved portrait of George D. Prentice, editor of the Louisville Journal
    George D. Prentice (1802–1870). Engraving from The American Portrait Gallery (1877).

    Whether Prentice caused the riot has been argued ever since, and the violence had more than one source. The clearer question is whether he wrote responsibly, and historians who have studied his editorials have generally concluded he did not. Three days after the riot, he wrote that he felt no cause for remorse and blamed the opposition papers. Years later, according to Bishop John Lancaster Spalding, nephew of the Louisville bishop who lived through the riot, he came to regret his part. Louisville’s German-language paper, the Anzeiger, had taken the opposite approach, urging German voters to go early, avoid crowds, and refuse to be provoked.

    Item from the Louisville Daily Journal of August 6, 1855, warning that if German voters provoked a collision at the polls there was but one way it could terminate
    From the Louisville Daily Journal, morning of August 6, 1855. Kentucky Digital Newspaper Program, University of Kentucky Libraries.

    Election Day, August 6, 1855

    The vote that Monday was a state election, for governor, Congress, and the legislature, not a city race. Armed Know-Nothing men took control of polling places early, some of them the night before. Voters who could not show they were with the party were jostled, threatened, or simply kept from reaching the window. In several wards, naturalized citizens with every legal right to vote were turned away, and hundreds of others stayed home rather than risk it.

    Fighting started in the morning and spread through the day. In the Sixth Ward, former congressman William Thomasson tried to calm a crowd and was struck from behind and beaten. In the afternoon, a brawl on Shelby Street, in the German section east of downtown, left more than a dozen men shot. Know-Nothing crowds broke into German coffeehouses and looted them. Around four o’clock in the afternoon, an armed mob turned toward St. Martin of Tours, the German Catholic church on Shelby Street. Later, a German brewery on Jefferson Street was set on fire. A German priest, Father Karl Boeswald, was struck by stones as he went to visit a dying parishioner, and died of his injuries.

    The mayor’s role is one of the stranger parts of the day. Barbee had asked for special police at the polls, but the city council refused, and on election day his party’s supporters held them. But when the crowd moved on St. Martin’s, Barbee went out in person and talked them back to the First Ward polling place. He is also credited with keeping the mob away from the Cathedral of the Assumption on Fifth Street. Both churches still stand. Bishop Martin John Spalding and a number of Protestant clergy spent the following days urging Catholics not to retaliate.

    Quinn’s Row

    The worst of the violence happened here. Late in the afternoon, on Main Street near Eleventh, a group of Know-Nothings attacked three Irishmen and knocked one of them down. Irish residents fired from upper windows along the block. At least two men in the crowd, a river worker named Rodes and a man named Graham, were killed. Accounts of the next few minutes are confused and partisan, and it is not possible now to say with certainty who shot whom.

    What followed is more clear. After dark, the mob set fire to a row of frame tenements on Main between Tenth and Eleventh, owned by an Irishman named Quinn and known as Quinn’s Row. Twelve buildings burned. Tenants who ran from the flames were shot as they came out, and some of the wounded could not get clear of the fire. Contemporary reports describe at least one man being pushed back into a burning building. The bodies of the dead were later taken to the Jefferson County Courthouse, which the Know-Nothings had used throughout the day as a stronghold and arsenal.

    How Many Died?

    The marker says “at least 22,” and that wording is careful for a reason. Contemporary counts ranged from 14 to more than 100, and no official inquiry was ever made. Historians today generally put the toll between 19 and 22, most of them Irish and German immigrants. Catholic sources at the time, including Bishop Spalding, believed the number was far higher, more than 100, on the grounds that whole families had died in the fires and were never counted. No one made a complete list. More than 100 homes, shops, and tenements were damaged, looted, or burned across the city, and the ruins on Main Street stood for years.

    The Aftermath

    The Know-Nothings won. Their candidate for governor, Charles S. Morehead, carried Kentucky by about 4,400 votes, the only governor the party ever elected in the state, and Louisville’s seat in Congress went to the party’s Humphrey Marshall. No one was held to account for the killings. A handful of men were indicted, and none was convicted. The victims were never compensated.

    Many immigrants concluded that Louisville was not safe for them. By some estimates, more than 10,000 people left over the next several years, many for St. Louis, Chicago, and Milwaukee, and the departures continued until the Civil War. Some historians have argued that the exodus helped St. Louis and Cincinnati pull ahead of Louisville as regional centers. Others think the effect has been overstated. Either way, a great many families who had chosen Louisville decided to start over somewhere else.

    The riot was noticed well beyond Kentucky. Less than three weeks later, on August 24, 1855, Abraham Lincoln wrote to his close friend Joshua Speed, who lived in Louisville (his nephew J.B. Speed is the namesake of the city’s Speed Art Museum), explaining why he could never join the Know-Nothings: “As a nation, we began by declaring that ‘all men are created equal.’ We now practically read it ‘all men are created equal, except negroes.’ When the Know-Nothings get control, it will read ‘all men are created equal, except negroes, and foreigners, and catholics.’”

    Reading the Reverse Side

    The reverse panel describes the party in a few sentences, and most of it holds up. A few phrases are worth a second look.

    “This party feared that Catholic immigrants … threatened Protestantism and democracy” states the Know-Nothings’ own view, and the marker is right to frame it as a fear rather than a fact. It is worth being plain about what happened on this street: the threat to democracy in Louisville on August 6 came from the men who seized the polls and kept citizens from voting.

    “By 1854, the party claimed a million members nationwide” is a fair figure. Membership was secret and no reliable count exists, but historians’ estimates for the movement’s peak in 1854 and 1855 are in that range. Only men could join, and about four million votes were cast in the 1856 presidential election, so a million members would have equaled roughly one in four of the men who voted.

    “They split over slavery” is correct, and it was the split, more than public revulsion at riots like this one, that ended the party. The break came at the party’s national meetings in 1855 and 1856, and after Millard Fillmore’s distant third-place finish as its presidential candidate in 1856, the American Party was finished as a national force. Northern Know-Nothings largely moved into the new Republican Party, and in Kentucky, most of the party’s voters drifted into opposition coalitions that became the Constitutional Union Party of 1860.

    That makes “by the end of the Civil War they had vanished” a generous endpoint. Some local officeholders elected as Know-Nothings stayed in Louisville politics into the late 1850s, but the party itself was gone years before the war ended. By 1865, Louisville had elected Philip Tomppert, a German immigrant, as mayor.

    Who Put the Marker Here

    Kentucky Lottery headquarters on West Main Street in Louisville, with Marker No. 2205 at the curb
    The marker at the curb in front of the Kentucky Lottery building, 1011 W. Main St.

    The marker was erected in 2006, a year after the riot’s 150th anniversary, with funding from two groups: the Ancient Order of Hibernians, an Irish Catholic fraternal organization, and Louisville’s German-American Club. Members of both communities have gathered at the site for small commemorations since then. As one organizer of the 150th-anniversary observance put it, “It’s important that Bloody Monday be remembered so that a similar event does not happen again.” The location was chosen with care. Of all the places the violence touched that day, from Shelby Street to the cathedral, this block was where it was worst.

    Caufield’s costume and novelty store on West Main Street in Louisville, across the street from the marker
    Caufield’s, across Main Street from the marker, on the old Quinn’s Row block.

    Today, the Cathedral of the Assumption and St. Martin of Tours are both active parishes, and the German and Irish neighborhoods the mobs attacked are part of the city’s identity. Quinn’s Row is gone. The only sign that it was here is the marker in front of the Lottery building.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker database; George H. Yater, “Bloody Monday,” in The Encyclopedia of Louisville (2001); Emmet V. Mittlebeeler, “The Aftermath of Louisville’s Bloody Monday Election Riot of 1855,” Filson Club History Quarterly 66, no. 2 (1992); William G. O’Toole Jr. and Charles E. Aebersold, trans., “Louisville’s Bloody Monday Riots from a German Perspective,” Filson Club History Quarterly 70, no. 4 (1996); Thomas D. Baldwin, “George D. Prentice, the Louisville Anzeiger, and the 1855 ‘Bloody Monday’ Riots,” Filson Club History Quarterly 67, no. 4 (1993); Louisville Daily Journal, August 6, 1855 (Kentucky Digital Newspaper Program, University of Kentucky Libraries); Abraham Lincoln to Joshua F. Speed, August 24, 1855, Collected Works of Abraham Lincoln; Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org); Clio, “‘Bloody Monday’ Riot Site”; Ancient Order of Hibernians, “Louisville’s Bloody Monday” (2018); Irish Echo, “Louisville’s ‘Bloody Monday’ is still remembered and marked” (2017); Wikipedia, “Bloody Monday,” “John Barbee,” “George D. Prentice,” “Charles S. Morehead,” and “Humphrey Marshall (general).”

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • “THOMAS HUNT MORGAN”
    Born in Lexington, Ky. on September 25, 1866, Morgan was a nephew of Confederate General John Hunt Morgan. He attended the State College of Kentucky (University of Kentucky) during the 1880s. Morgan graduated as valedictorian in 1886 with a B.S. and an M.S. in 1888. He earned a Ph.D. from Johns Hopkins University in 1890. Class of 2010.

    “THOMAS HUNT MORGAN, 1866–1945”
    Morgan discovered the basic mechanisms of heredity and was a pioneering geneticist, winning the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1933. In 1966, the University named the new Thomas Hunt Morgan School of Biological Sciences for him. Class of 2010.

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2342 — erected 2011

    Front of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2342, a dark green cast-metal plaque topped by the University of Kentucky seal, on a campus lawn.
    Front of the marker
    Reverse of Marker No. 2342, headed “Thomas Hunt Morgan, 1866–1945,” with trees and a brick building behind it.
    Reverse of the marker

    Thomas Hunt Morgan Building, 195 Huguelet Dr., University of Kentucky, Lexington | 38° 02′ 02″ N, 84° 30′ 20″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    Most of Lexington’s historical markers stand on roadsides. This one stands on a campus lawn, in front of a concrete and brick science building named for the man on the plaque. It carries the University of Kentucky seal instead of the Commonwealth’s, and it was paid for by the graduating Class of 2010, who chose Thomas Hunt Morgan as their gift to the school. It was dedicated in April 2011.

    The marker tells a clean story of a local student who went on to win the Nobel Prize, and a university that honored him. Every fact on it is correct. What it leaves out is the decade in between, when Kentucky came within one vote of making the science Morgan practiced illegal to teach in its public schools, including at the university that later put his name on a building.

    A Lexington Boy at State College

    Black-and-white studio portrait of Thomas Hunt Morgan in profile, with a full beard, dark suit and high white collar.
    Thomas Hunt Morgan as a young biologist. Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

    Morgan was born in 1866 into two prominent families. His mother, Ellen Key Howard, was a granddaughter of Francis Scott Key; his father, Charlton Hunt Morgan, was the brother of John Hunt Morgan, the Confederate cavalry raider whose statue stood on the old courthouse lawn until 2017. The family home was Hopemont, the Hunt-Morgan House on Gratz Park, which has its own marker, No. 2365. A second Thomas Hunt Morgan marker, No. 1714, stands nearby on North Broadway.

    At sixteen he entered the State College of Kentucky, the school that became the University of Kentucky. He graduated first in his class in 1886 with a bachelor of science degree, spent several summers doing geological and biological fieldwork in the Kentucky mountains, and received a master’s degree from State College in 1888. By then he was already at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, one of the first American universities built around laboratory research. He finished his doctorate there in 1890 with a study of the embryos of sea spiders.

    The marker’s front panel stops at that point. Morgan never lived in Kentucky again.

    The Fly Room

    After more than a decade teaching at Bryn Mawr College, Morgan moved to Columbia University in New York in 1904. Around 1908 he began breeding fruit flies, Drosophila melanogaster, in milk bottles in a cramped laboratory that became known as the Fly Room. Fruit flies were cheap, bred quickly, and had only four pairs of chromosomes.

    Detailed black-and-white engraving of a fruit fly in side view, showing its large compound eye, bristled body, striped abdomen and long wing.
    Drosophila melanogaster, the common fruit fly at the center of Morgan’s work. Engraving from the Encyclopædia Britannica (1918).

    In 1910 Morgan found a male fly with white eyes instead of the usual red. When he bred it and tracked the trait through later generations, white eyes showed up almost entirely in males. The simplest explanation was that the gene for eye color rode on the same chromosome that determines sex. It was some of the first hard evidence that genes are physical things, located on chromosomes, rather than a convenient abstraction.

    The marker credits Morgan with discovering “the basic mechanisms of heredity,” and that needs a little context. Gregor Mendel had worked out the basic rules of inheritance in pea plants in the 1860s. What Morgan’s lab showed was the physical machinery behind those rules. And it was a team effort. His students Alfred Sturtevant, Calvin Bridges, and Hermann Muller did much of the work; Sturtevant, still an undergraduate, drew the first map of genes along a chromosome. In 1915 the four men published The Mechanism of Mendelian Heredity together. When Morgan received the Nobel Prize in 1933, “for his discoveries concerning the role played by the chromosome in heredity,” he shared the prize money with the families of Sturtevant and Bridges.

    There is one more wrinkle. Morgan did not start out as a champion of Darwin. In his 1903 book Evolution and Adaptation, he openly doubted that natural selection could account for new species. He never doubted that evolution happened; he doubted the explanation. The fly work changed his mind. Genetics showed how new variations arise and how they are passed down, which was exactly the piece Darwin’s theory had been missing. By the 1920s, the onetime skeptic was one of the scientists whose work made evolution harder to argue with.

    Kentucky Takes Up Darwin

    Back home, the University of Kentucky had already claimed him, awarding Morgan an honorary doctor of laws degree in 1916. Six years later, the state legislature nearly outlawed the subject he was famous for.

    The campaign began in 1921 with a Baptist minister, J. W. Porter, who persuaded the Kentucky Baptist State Board of Missions to take up the cause and declared that “Darwinism would be run out of Kentucky if it took every cent the Baptist people of the Commonwealth had to do it.” On January 19, 1922, William Jennings Bryan, three times the Democratic nominee for president and the country’s best-known opponent of evolution, addressed a joint session of the Kentucky House and Senate in Frankfort. Four days later, Representative George W. Ellis of Barren County introduced House Bill 191.

    The bill would have banned the teaching of “Darwinism, atheism, agnosticism or evolution as it pertains to the origin of man” in public schools and “other public institutions of learning.” A teacher who broke the law faced a fine of $50 to $5,000, up to a year in jail, or both. A school that allowed it could lose its charter. A companion measure in the Senate, sponsored by James R. Rash of Madisonville, was sent to the Rules Committee by a vote of 19 to 17, which effectively ended it. The House bill went to the floor.

    Forty-Two to Forty-One

    The university’s president, Frank L. McVey, took the unusual step of fighting the bill in public. He confirmed that the university taught evolution and said it would keep doing so. Testifying before a Senate committee in February, he argued that the law would make it impossible to find usable science textbooks, would push Kentucky students to schools in other states, and would violate the personal liberties the state constitution protected. He presented evolution as a theory of development and change, not an attack on religious faith.

    Black-and-white photograph of a white-haired Frank L. McVey seated outdoors in a light suit and striped tie, holding a pen over a writing board.
    Frank L. McVey, president of the University of Kentucky from 1917 to 1940. Portrait by Doris Ulmann; University of Oregon Libraries.

    Not every religious leader was on the other side. Some Kentucky ministers spoke against the bill, and the president of the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, E. Y. Mullins, favored a narrower measure that would protect students’ religious beliefs rather than ban a scientific theory outright.

    In March 1922 the House voted down House Bill 191, 42 to 41. Historians of the creationism movement count it as the first bill in American history aimed squarely at the teaching of evolution, and it failed by a single vote. Arthur M. Miller, the university’s geology professor and one of McVey’s allies, wrote up the fight for the national journal Science that spring.

    A Student Named Scopes

    One of the students on campus that spring was a law major from Paducah named John Thomas Scopes. Born in 1900, he had grown up partly in Illinois, and in 1919 he graduated from high school in Salem, Illinois, where the commencement speaker was William Jennings Bryan. A health problem led him to transfer from the University of Illinois to the University of Kentucky at the start of his second year of college. He took a minor in geology, studied under Arthur Miller, and graduated in 1924.

    Two men in straw boater hats and round glasses standing outdoors. Rappleyea, left, wears a suit and holds a cigarette; Scopes, right, is in shirtsleeves and a striped tie.
    George W. Rappleyea (left) and John T. Scopes in Dayton, Tennessee, 1925. Photograph by Watson Davis, Science Service; Smithsonian Institution Archives.

    That fall Scopes took a job coaching football and teaching algebra and physics at Rhea County High School in Dayton, Tennessee. In March 1925, Tennessee passed the Butler Act, which did what Kentucky had narrowly refused to do: it made it a crime to teach that humans descended from a lower order of animals. When the American Civil Liberties Union offered to defend any teacher willing to test the law, a group of Dayton businessmen saw a chance to put their town on the map. Scopes, who had filled in for the regular biology teacher, agreed to be charged. He said later that he was not sure he had ever actually taught the evolution lesson.

    The trial, in July 1925, became a national spectacle. Bryan joined the prosecution; Clarence Darrow led the defense. Scopes was found guilty and fined $100. Tennessee’s Supreme Court later threw out the verdict on a technicality. Bryan died in Dayton five days after the trial ended. Scopes left teaching, studied geology in graduate school at the University of Chicago, and spent the rest of his career as a petroleum geologist. He died in 1970.

    Where Was Morgan?

    Morgan, still at Columbia, does not appear in accounts of the Kentucky fight, and he played no part in the Scopes trial. His contribution that year came in print. In 1925, the year Dayton made headlines, Princeton University Press published his book Evolution and Genetics, which laid out the genetic case for evolution. It also contained an early critique of eugenics from one of the field’s leading figures: Morgan cautioned that mental and social traits are heavily shaped by environment, and that claims about inheriting them ran well ahead of the evidence.

    So the timeline the marker compresses into two panels looks like this. Kentucky trained Morgan and honored him in 1916. In 1922 its legislature nearly made his field a crime to teach. In 1925 a graduate of the same university became the defendant in the most famous evolution trial in American history. Morgan moved to the California Institute of Technology in 1928, won the Nobel Prize in 1933, and died in Pasadena in 1945. The university inducted him into its Hall of Distinguished Alumni in 1965 and, in 1966, the centennial of his birth, gave his name to the new School of Biological Sciences it formed by merging the Departments of Botany, Microbiology, and Zoology.

    None of that is a reason to discount the honor. The university took a stand when it counted, and McVey’s defense of evolution in 1922 was one of the reasons the bill failed. But the marker presents Morgan’s connection to Kentucky as a straight line from valedictorian to namesake, and the real story has a near miss in the middle of it.

    An Argument That Never Quite Ended

    In 2019, the university added a plaque inside newly renovated Miller Hall, named for the same Arthur Miller, honoring Miller, McVey, and Scopes as early defenders of teaching evolution. It came about through the efforts of two retired university scientists. Miller Hall also has its own state historical marker, No. 1953.

    The question Kentucky voted on in 1922 did not go away. In 1976 the General Assembly passed a law allowing public school teachers to present “the theory of creation as presented in the Bible” alongside evolution. Fifty-four years after the House rejected a ban by one vote, the legislature opened the classroom door from the other side.

    Wide view of a three-story concrete-and-brick building, its ground floor set back behind columns, partly screened by trees.
    The Thomas Hunt Morgan Building on the University of Kentucky campus.

    Standing on the lawn in front of the Thomas Hunt Morgan Building, students walk past a marker celebrating a geneticist from Lexington. Across campus, in Miller Hall, a second plaque remembers the year the state nearly decided that what he discovered could not be taught there.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker database, Marker No. 2342; UKNow, “Annual Marker Honors Bio Alum, Nobel Winner” (2011); University of Kentucky Department of Biology, “History” and “UK’s Impact on Evolution”; Lexington History Museum, “Morgan, Thomas Hunt”; National Academy of Sciences, Biographical Memoir of Thomas Hunt Morgan; The Nobel Prize, Physiology or Medicine 1933; Wikipedia, “Thomas Hunt Morgan,” “John T. Scopes,” and “John Hunt Morgan Memorial”; Jane Maienschein, “Thomas Hunt Morgan,” Encyclopedia of Evolution (2002); Thomas Hunt Morgan, Evolution and Adaptation (1903) and Evolution and Genetics (1925); Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory DNA Learning Center, “The Inheritance of Mental Traits”; Arthur M. Miller, account of the Kentucky evolution bill in Science (1922); “The Kentucky Campaign Against the Teaching of Evolution,” The Journal of Religion (May 1922); National Center for Science Education, “Martin’s Mysterious Myrmidons” and “One Hundred Years of Anti-Evolution Legislation Are More Than Enough”; Glenn Branch, Religion Dispatches (2022); John T. Scopes, “Reflections” (1965), via Famous Trials; Kentucky Kernel, “UK supported evolution before it was cool”; The Panda’s Thumb, “Kentucky (yes, Kentucky) erects plaque honoring early defenders of evolution” (2019); The Kaintuckeean, “The Thomas Hunt Morgan Biological Sciences Building.”

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Front panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2468 at St. Paul Catholic Church, Lexington
    Reverse panel of Kentucky Historical Society Marker No. 2468 at St. Paul Catholic Church, Lexington

    “The cornerstone was laid on Nov. 12, 1865 and church consecrated by the Rt. Rev. G.A. Carroll, Bishop of Covington, on Oct. 18, 1868. The remains of the first pastor, Fr. Bekkers, are interred in a vault in the narthex of the church. In 1909, St. Paul was divided into two separate and distinct parishes due to substantial growth.”

    “The church is a fine example of Gothic Revival architecture. At the time of completion, the 210-foot bell tower was the tallest in the city. Clocks from Boston added in 1883 were the city’s first church tower clocks. The twelve single-panel stained glass windows were designed and manufactured by G. C. Riordan Co. in Cincinnati.”

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2468 — erected 2015

    425 W. Short St., Lexington | 38° 03′ 01″ N, 84° 30′ 00″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    Vertical panorama of the brick Gothic Revival facade of St. Paul Catholic Church on West Short Street, from the three arched doorways to the tower and spire
    St. Paul Catholic Church, from the arched doorways to the spire.

    Stand on the sidewalk in front of St. Paul and look up. The brick facade climbs in stages, from the three Gothic-arched doorways, each capped by a stone hood mold, past the tall center window and the Latin inscription, to a square tower, a clock, and finally a slate spire topped with a cross. The inscription over the main door reads “Ecclesia Sancti Pauli Apostoli, Aedificata 1865, Consecrata”: the Church of St. Paul the Apostle, built 1865, consecrated. It is a building designed to be seen from a distance, and for a time it could be seen from farther away than anything else in Lexington.

    The marker packs a lot into two panels: a cornerstone, a consecration, a pastor in a vault, a parish split, a record-setting tower, Boston clocks, and Cincinnati glass. Most of it holds up. A few pieces deserve a closer look, including one detail that cannot be right as written.

    A Parish Older Than Its Church

    St. Paul’s congregation is much older than the building on Short Street. Catholic settlers in the Lexington area asked Archbishop John Carroll of Baltimore for a priest in the early 1790s. Father Stephen Theodore Badin arrived in 1793 to serve several scattered Kentucky settlements. For years, Mass was said in private homes. By 1801 the faithful had a log chapel between Main and Short Streets, known by 1808 as St. Peter’s.

    On St. Patrick’s Day, 1811, Father Badin and Father Thomas O’Flynn started a subscription drive for a permanent church. Two years later the congregation paid $312 for a lot owned by General Robert Todd and his wife, Nancy Ann. Todd, one of Lexington’s founders and a great-uncle of Mary Todd Lincoln, died the following year. A small brick Gothic chapel soon went up on the lot, on Third Street east of North Limestone. In 1837 the parish moved into a larger church on North Limestone, then called Mulberry Street, paid for in part by money Father Edward McMahon raised on a fundraising tour of New Orleans.

    So when the cornerstone of St. Paul was laid, Lexington’s Catholics were not founding something new. They were moving an existing parish, with more than seventy years of history, into a much larger and far more visible home. The old North Limestone church was kept as a mission. That detail matters later in the story. (Even some modern references blur this lineage and describe St. Paul as the city’s first Catholic church, built in 1813. The 1813 church was St. Peter’s.)

    Building a Landmark in 1865

    Detail from an 1871 bird’s-eye view map of downtown Lexington, Kentucky
    Detail from A. Ruger, Bird’s Eye View of the City of Lexington, Fayette County, Kentucky, 1871. Library of Congress, Geography and Map Division.

    Father John H. Bekkers became pastor in 1864. The design work went to Piket & Son of Cincinnati, a firm often recorded under the anglicized spelling Pickett. Anton Piket and his son Louis specialized in Catholic churches, and by 1865 they had already designed two Cincinnati landmarks: Immaculata Church, completed in 1859 on the heights of Mount Adams, and St. Francis Xavier Church downtown, completed in 1860. According to the 1975 National Register nomination for Lexington’s Western Suburb Historic District, the local builder was either Cincinnatus Shryock or Julian S. Hoagland. The cornerstone was laid in November 1865, only months after the Civil War ended.

    The timing gives the building a meaning the marker leaves out. A decade earlier, Kentucky had been a stronghold of the Know Nothing movement, a political party built largely on hostility to Catholic immigrants, most of them Irish and German. In 1855 the party won the governor’s office, and on election day that August, nativist mobs in Louisville kept Catholics from the polls; the rioting known as Bloody Monday left 22 people dead. Nothing comparable happened in Lexington, and there is no direct link between the riot and St. Paul. But every Catholic in the state lived through that period, and the memory was recent when the congregation decided to build. The political party collapsed within a few years, and Catholics’ service on both sides of the Civil War did much to blunt the old charge that they could not be loyal Americans.

    Against that background, the scale of the new church stands out. A congregation that had worshiped in a log chapel, and then in modest buildings off the main streets, chose to put up a Gothic church on a prominent downtown lot, with a bell tower taller than any other structure in the city. The effect was plain. After 1868, anyone looking at Lexington’s skyline saw a Catholic cross at the top of it.

    The Bishop Who Could Not Have Been There

    The marker says the church was consecrated “by the Rt. Rev. G.A. Carroll, Bishop of Covington, on Oct. 18, 1868.” That sentence has two problems.

    The first is the spelling. Lexington fell within the Diocese of Covington from 1853 until the Diocese of Lexington was created in 1988, and Covington’s first bishop was George Aloysius Carrell, spelled with an ‘e’. The marker spells the name like that of Archbishop John Carroll, the first Catholic bishop in the United States, a far more familiar name and an easy mix-up.

    The second problem is harder to explain. Bishop Carrell died in Covington on September 25, 1868, more than three weeks before the date on the marker. He could not have consecrated the church in October.

    Either the date or the name is wrong. The consecration may have taken place earlier in 1868, while Carrell was still alive, or another bishop may have presided in October, after his death. The parish’s own history says only that the church was “dedicated and consecrated in 1868.” We have not found a contemporary account that settles the question. If you know of one, a newspaper notice or a diocesan record, we would like to hear from you.

    Father Bekkers

    The marker gives Father Bekkers a single line, noting that his remains lie in a vault in the narthex, the entry hall just inside the front doors. He deserves more detail. Bekkers was the pastor who saw the church built, and his work reached well beyond Short Street. He opened the parish school, helped establish St. Joseph Hospital, which the Sisters of Charity of Nazareth founded in Lexington in 1877, and acquired the land for Calvary Cemetery, which is still in use today.

    Burial inside a church was an honor usually reserved for founders and benefactors. For the parishioners who walk through the narthex each week, the man who built the place is, in a literal sense, still at the door.

    Clocks, Glass, and a Very Tall Tower

    The clock, belfry, and slate spire of the bell tower at St. Paul Catholic Church, Lexington
    The tower clock and spire.

    The marker’s reverse side panel turns from people to the building itself. The tower clocks, purchased from Boston and installed in 1883, are described as the first church tower clocks in the city, and the parish’s newspaper record confirms a new clock that year.

    The twelve single-panel stained glass windows are credited to the G. C. Riordan Company of Cincinnati. That detail raises a question about when they were installed. The studio traces its roots to a Cincinnati glass shop opened in 1838, but it did not carry the Riordan name until the early 1890s, when Gerald Collins Riordan, an Irish immigrant who had managed the business since 1884, bought it and renamed it G. C. Riordan & Co. If the windows were made by the firm under that name, they are not original to 1868 but part of a later round of work, a common pattern as parishes replaced plain early glass with pictorial windows once they could afford it. The National Register nomination supports that reading. It describes the windows as memorials to distinguished Lexingtonians, among them Col. E. R. Bradley, the horseman whose Idle Hour Farm produced four Kentucky Derby winners. Riordan glass is a familiar sight in the region; much of the stained glass in the Victorian houses of Newport, Kentucky’s East Row Historic District came from the same studio. The company still operates today as BeauVerre Riordan Studios in Middletown, Ohio, and describes itself as the oldest continuously operating stained glass studio in the country.

    The marker does not mention another notable feature in the church: fourteen Stations of the Cross, painted in oil on canvas in 1884 and 1885 by Julius Frank (1826–1908), a Munich history painter trained at the city’s Academy of Fine Arts, whose other work includes altarpieces for Bavarian churches, a mural cycle for the Bavarian National Museum, and frescoes at Stonyhurst College in England.

    The claim that the 210-foot tower was the tallest structure in Lexington is repeated in nearly every account of the church, but we could not find an independent measurement or a comparison with the city’s other steeples of the 1860s. It is very likely true. Lexington in 1870 was a city of roughly 15,000 people, with no commercial buildings anywhere near that height. Still, it is best understood as parish tradition rather than a documented record.

    “Due to Substantial Growth”

    The marker’s account of 1909 is accurate as far as it goes: on June 27 of that year, St. Paul was divided, and 291 families were assigned to a new parish. The marker does not say which parish that was.

    It was St. Peter. The name Lexington’s first Catholic congregation had carried since the log chapel days, reduced to a mission when St. Paul opened in 1868, became a full parish again under Father William Punch. The new parish’s members worshiped in the old North Limestone church, which had been kept as a mission for four decades, until they could build their own. Their present church on Barr Street was dedicated on April 7, 1929.

    The growth was real. Lexington had gone from about 16,600 people in 1880 to more than 35,000 by 1910, and one downtown parish was no longer enough. But “substantial growth” explains why the division happened, not what it was.

    Two Churches, One Beginning

    St. Paul marked its centennial in 1968 with a remodeling project that cost about $200,000. Twenty years later, when the Diocese of Lexington was created from parts of the Diocese of Covington and the Archdiocese of Louisville, the church became part of a diocese based in its own city for the first time.

    The longer thread, though, is the one the marker skips. Lexington today has both churches: St. Paul on Short Street and St. Peter on Barr Street, on opposite sides of downtown. Both trace their roots to the same log chapel and to Father Badin’s arrival in 1793. In 1868, St. Paul got the landmark, and St. Peter kept the name, waiting as a mission in its old church on North Limestone.

    Read that way, “divided into two separate and distinct parishes due to substantial growth” undersells what happened in 1909. The parish that separated from St. Paul was not an offshoot. It was the original, returning after forty years because the city had finally grown enough to need it again. Standing under the tower on Short Street, you are looking at the building that replaced Lexington’s first Catholic parish. Across downtown, the parish it replaced is still holding Mass.

    Sources consulted: Historic St. Paul Catholic Church, parish history (saintpaul.cdlex.org); St. Peter Catholic Church, “Our History” (stpeterlex.org); Kentucky Historical Society marker database; National Register of Historic Places, Western Suburb Historic District nomination (1975); Michigan Technological University, Copper Country Architects, “Louis Piket”; Wikipedia, “Immaculata Church” and “St. Francis Xavier Church (Cincinnati, Ohio)”; Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org), entry 119120; Kenton County Public Library, biography of Bishop George Aloysius Carrell; Diocese of Covington, “19th century Know Nothings and anti-Catholicism”; BeauVerre Riordan Studios, company history; WVXU, “OKI Wanna Know: What’s with all the stained glass windows in some neighborhoods?”; Wikipedia (German), “Julius Frank (Maler)”; Wikipedia, “Robert Todd (pioneer)”; Wikipedia, “George Aloysius Carrell,” “Roman Catholic Diocese of Lexington,” and “Timeline of Lexington, Kentucky.”

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Dr. Luke P. Blackburn Correctional Complex
    Originally Kentucky Village, this complex renamed in honor of Dr. Luke P. Blackburn, 26th Governor of Ky., in recognition of his pioneer efforts in prison reform. Elected Governor in 1879, after campaigning to relieve conditions at Frankfort Penitentiary, he asked for drastic changes in penal system in first message to legislature.

    Blackburn Correctional Complex
    In 1880 prison reform finally began. Abolition of the lessee system soon followed. Governor Luke P. Blackburn’s efforts resulted in creation of the Kentucky State Penitentiary at Eddyville. Dr. Blackburn also noted for treating epidemics in parts of U.S. and other countries. Native of Woodford County, born 1816, he singlehandedly fought great epidemic of cholera there, 1835.

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 1466 — erected 1973

    Blackburn Correctional Complex, 3111 Spurr Road, Lexington | 38° 06′ 36″ N, 84° 32′ 16″ W — Directions: MapQuest

    This marker stands just outside the security fence of a working state prison on Spurr Road, northwest of downtown Lexington. It can be read from the roadside, and that is as close as most visitors will get. Its two sides tell a tidy story: a physician-governor who cleaned up Kentucky’s prisons and fought epidemics at home and abroad. Every claim on it has a basis in the record. What the marker leaves out is the episode that made Luke Blackburn’s name notorious across the North, fifteen years before Kentucky elected him, and the fine print behind its most confident sentence.

    Luke Pryor Blackburn (1816–1887), M.D.

    Portrait of Dr. Luke P. Blackburn
    Luke Pryor Blackburn (1816–1887)

    Blackburn grew up in Woodford County, one of thirteen children in a family long active in Kentucky politics. At sixteen he began a medical apprenticeship under his uncle, Dr. Churchill Blackburn, and helped him treat cholera patients during outbreaks in Lexington and Paris. He earned his medical degree from Transylvania University in 1835 and opened a practice in Lexington.

    That same year cholera reached Versailles, the seat of his home county. Cholera kills through violent diarrhea and vomiting that can dehydrate a victim within hours, and no one yet knew that it spread through contaminated water. Epidemics emptied towns as residents, and often their doctors, fled. By one account, roughly fifteen percent of Woodford County’s population died. Blackburn went to Versailles, worked through the epidemic, and accepted no payment. The grateful townspeople persuaded him to stay, and in 1843 Woodford County sent him to the state legislature.

    The marker says he fought that epidemic “singlehandedly.” The word comes from a story often told about him: that he was the only doctor who stayed in Versailles while the disease raged. That may well be true. But it comes from admiring later accounts, not from records kept at the time, so it is better read as a tribute than as a documented fact.

    His reputation grew after he moved to Natchez, Mississippi, in 1847. He served as the city’s health officer and in 1848 imposed what is credited as the first successful quarantine against yellow fever in the Mississippi Valley. He built a hospital for river boatmen with his own money, then persuaded Congress to fund a federal hospital at Natchez.

    When yellow fever broke out near New York City in the 1850s, the mayor asked him to help, and again he refused payment. By the eve of the Civil War he was one of the best-known yellow fever physicians in the country.

    The Trunks, 1864–1865

    Blackburn’s sympathies lay with the Confederate States of America (CSA). Too old to enlist, he served as an envoy for Kentucky Governor Beriah Magoffin, as a surgeon on General Sterling Price’s staff, and, from 1863, as an agent in Canada supplying Confederate blockade runners.

    In April 1864 yellow fever struck Bermuda, a British colony that had become a major base for those same CSA blockade runners. Britain was officially neutral in the war, but its island ports were where Confederate ships loaded the goods they tried to slip past the Union navy. Blackburn sailed to Bermuda at the request of Canada’s British governor general and treated the sick through the summer and again that fall. For that work he received a commendation from Queen Victoria, whose government ruled both Canada and Bermuda.

    Harbor at St. George's, Bermuda
    St. George’s Harbor, Bermuda. Wikimedia Commons.

    According to later testimony, he was also collecting the bedding and clothing of patients who had died. Why, you may ask? In April 1865, a man named Godfrey Joseph Hyams walked into the U.S. consulate in Toronto with an unusual report. Blackburn, he said, had hired him to smuggle wooden trunks of those garments from Bermuda into Boston, Philadelphia, Washington, and the Union-occupied ports of New Bern and Norfolk, and to sell the contents to used-clothing dealers. The goal was to create an epidemic behind Union lines. Hyams also claimed Blackburn had packed a valise of fine dress shirts to be delivered to President Lincoln as a gift from an anonymous admirer. Hyams refused the errand.

    Two days later, as we know well, Abraham Lincoln was shot by John Wilkes Booth. Federal officials, eager to tie the assassination to Jefferson Davis and his agents in Canada, took Hyams seriously. So did authorities in Bermuda, who had separate information that Blackburn had left three more trunks with a St. George’s hotel keeper named Edward Swan, to be shipped to New York City the following spring. They raided the hotel, found the trunks, and reported stains consistent with the “black vomit” of late-stage yellow fever. The contents were soaked in sulfuric acid and buried.

    Canadian police arrested Blackburn on May 19, 1865. Under British law a conspiracy-to-murder charge required a head of state as the intended victim, so he was tried instead for violating Canadian neutrality. In October 1865 a Toronto court acquitted him on the grounds that the trunks had moved through Nova Scotia, outside its jurisdiction. Blackburn never testified. Years later he dismissed the whole affair as “too preposterous for intelligent gentlemen to believe.”

    The story is even more complex, as historians still disagree about how strong the case was. Hyams was paid for his testimony and granted immunity, several witnesses were men of doubtful character, and many relevant records have been lost. The accusations also arrived at the height of post-assassination suspicion of anything Confederate. On the other side, at least one leading historian of the Lincoln assassination argues that enough evidence survives to establish Blackburn’s role, and to show that senior Confederate officials knew of and financed the scheme.

    Engraving of the Aedes aegypti mosquito, carrier of yellow fever
    Aedes aegypti, the yellow fever mosquito.

    One thing is not in dispute. The plan could never have worked. Yellow fever does not travel on cloth; it is carried by the Aedes aegypti mosquito, a link confirmed by a U.S. Army commission decades later in 1900. Blackburn shared the common belief of his era that the disease spread by contact. The science tells us the trunks were harmless. It says nothing about what the man who packed them intended.

    “The Hero of Hickman,” 1867–1879

    Blackburn stayed in Canada to avoid federal prosecution. In September 1867, hearing of yellow fever in New Orleans and along the Texas coast, he wrote to President Andrew Johnson asking permission to come home and help. He crossed the border without waiting for a reply, which never came. No one arrested him. After living for a period on an Arkansas plantation owned by his wife, he settled in Louisville, Kentucky, in 1873.

    For the next five years he rebuilt his name. During Louisville’s 1873 cholera outbreak he argued, correctly, that contaminated water spread the disease and urged residents to boil it, advice most ignored in favor of the prevailing miasma theory, which blamed “bad air.” He treated yellow fever in Memphis, Tennessee, in 1873 and Fernandina, Florida, in 1877, again declining payment. In early 1878, while beginning a campaign to run for governor, he persuaded the General Assembly to create a state board of health.

    That September, the mayor of Hickman, a small Mississippi River town in Kentucky’s far west, telegraphed the new board for help. Roughly a fifth of the town was sick with yellow fever. Blackburn arrived within days, organized cleanup crews, left when the outbreak seemed to wane, and came back when it surged again into nearby Fulton. When it finally ended, Louisville fêted him for weeks as the “Hero of Hickman.” The Democratic nomination for governor followed, 935 delegates to 22.

    The Bermuda story resurfaced during the 1879 campaign, when the Cincinnati Gazette assigned a team to investigate it and Northern papers mocked him as “Dr. Blackvomit.” The attacks gained little ground in Kentucky. The Louisville editor Henry Watterson judged that most Kentuckians already knew what Blackburn had done during the war and either approved or no longer cared. He won with 56 percent of the vote, the largest Democratic margin in a decade.

    Governor Blackburn and the Frankfort Penitentiary

    The prison in Frankfort that Blackburn inherited was a public health disaster. By his count, 953 inmates were crowded into 780 cells. Three-quarters of the prisoners suffered from scurvy, and the annual death rate exceeded seven percent. Blackburn compared the place to the Black Hole of Calcutta.

    Historic bird's-eye view map of Frankfort, Kentucky
    Bird’s-eye view of Frankfort. Library of Congress.

    Much of the problem came from what the marker calls the “lessee system.” For decades, Kentucky had not run its own penitentiary. Instead, the legislature leased the entire prison to a private businessman, the lessee, who paid the state for the privilege. In return he fed, clothed, and guarded the prisoners, and he kept the profits from their labor. Every dollar he saved on food, blankets, or medicine was a dollar in his pocket. Lessees kept legislators friendly with perks such as free meals and cheap laundry service. One longtime lessee, Jeremiah South, was said to control the legislature as firmly as he controlled the convicts.

    Before the legislature acted, Blackburn used the tool already in his hands: the pardon. He favored clemency especially for the incurably ill, so they could go home to die with their families. Over his term he pardoned more than a thousand people, among them, in 1883, Lexington’s most famous madam, Belle Brezing, convicted of keeping a “bawdy house.” Critics called him “Lenient Luke,” and some newspapers claimed he sold pardons for two dollars apiece, a charge for which no evidence has been found.

    In 1880 the General Assembly approved the reforms the marker describes: a new penitentiary at Eddyville, a state-employed warden and staff to replace the lessee at Frankfort, and the state’s first rudimentary parole process. His administration also reorganized the Agricultural and Mechanical College at Lexington under state control, the institution that would become the University of Kentucky. The marker records his standing as a reformer, and a biographer’s description of him as the father of prison reform in Kentucky has followed him ever since.

    What “Abolition of the Lessee System” Left Out

    The marker’s reverse says abolition of the lessee system “soon followed.” That is accurate for the arrangement it names: after 1880, no private lessee ran the Frankfort penitentiary. But as a way of relieving overcrowding, the same legislature allowed private contractors to lease prisoners’ labor for work outside the walls, with the contractors responsible for feeding, housing, and caring for the men in their charge. There was little oversight. Malnutrition, overwork, and beatings followed, and some prisoners were injured or killed.

    In other words, one form of private profit from prisoners ended while another expanded. Kentucky’s arrangement developed alongside the convict-lease systems spreading across the postwar South, where leased labor in mines, on railroads, and on farms fell overwhelmingly on Black prisoners. The marker’s single sentence reads as the end of a story that in fact continued for decades. The questions raised in Frankfort in 1880, about who profits when prisons are run for profit and who watches the operators, have not gone away.

    Blackburn’s reforms made him unpopular at home. Party leaders resented his pardons and his refusal to hand out state jobs as rewards for party loyalty. When he rose to defend his record at the 1883 Democratic convention, boos nearly drowned him out. He answered that anyone who accused his administration of corruption was a “liar—a base and infamous liar”!

    Conversely, that September, at the National Conference of Charities and Correction in Louisville, the New Orleans novelist George Washington Cable, author of The Grandissimes, praised Blackburn’s prison reforms before a national audience. Cable came to that meeting with a paper condemning the convict-lease system across the South.

    Kentucky Village, 1897–1972

    The prison that now carries Blackburn’s name began as something else. In 1897 the legislature established the Kentucky House of Reform on 200 acres at Greendale in Fayette County. Boys and girls from eight to twenty-one were sent there and put to work on the farm and in a rock quarry; formal vocational training did not begin until the late 1940s. Whippings, solitary confinement in “the hole,” and leg chains weighted with thirty-five pounds were used to keep order.

    The institution was later renamed Kentucky Village, though many knew it as the Greendale Reform School. In 1970, early in his term, Governor Louie B. Nunn paid a surprise visit and was appalled by what he found. The state moved juveniles to a system of regional centers organized by age and offense, and the Greendale grounds were turned over to the adult corrections system. The minimum-security prison that opened there in 1972 was named for Luke Blackburn, and this marker followed in 1973. Today it is the state’s largest minimum-security institution for adult men.

    The Good Samaritan

    Blackburn left office in 1883 and returned to medicine in Louisville. There he opened and ran a sanatorium, a private residential hospital where patients with long-term illnesses came for rest and extended care, near Cave Hill Cemetery on the city’s east side. It struggled as his own health failed. In January 1887 he went back to Frankfort, the city he considered home, and died there on September 14. In 1891 the Commonwealth placed a granite monument over his grave in Frankfort Cemetery. Its bas-relief depicts the Parable of the Good Samaritan.

    Engraving of the Blackburn monument in Frankfort Cemetery with its Good Samaritan bas-relief
    Blackburn monument, Frankfort Cemetery.

    Ninety years apart, the state honored him twice, once with a monument to his mercy and once with a prison named for his reforms. Neither mentions the events in Bermuda.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society Marker Database (No. 1466); Historical Marker Database (HMdb) entry for Marker 1466; Kentucky Historical Society, Kentucky Ancestors, “The George Blackburn Family of Leaders”; The Kentucky Encyclopedia (University Press of Kentucky); Luke Pryor Blackburn: Physician, Governor, Reformer (University Press of Kentucky, 1979); Kentucky’s Governors (University Press of Kentucky); National Governors Association, governor biography; Science History Institute, “Yellow Fever Fiend”; “The ‘Yellow Fever Plot’: Biological Warfare in the American Civil War” (PubMed Central); Southern Poverty Law Center, “Criminalizing Blackness: Prisons, Police and Jim Crow”; Kentucky Historic Institutions, “Kentucky House of Reform”; Kentucky Department of Corrections, Blackburn Correctional Complex.

    Buy Me a Coffee
  • Listen to this story

    Narration is AI-generated from the text of this article.

    Joyland Park, Paris Pike, 1923‑64

    Home of the Wildcat rollercoaster, Joyland Railroad, a midway, Fayette Co.’s first public swimming pool & a dance casino featuring jazz and big bands like Duke Ellington & Artie Shaw, as well as local & regional entertainers. The segregated park provided picnic areas, July 4th fireworks & fun for many children.

    Joyland Neighborhood Association

    Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 2568 — erected 2019

    Kentucky historical marker No. 2568 for Joyland Park on Paris Pike

    2375 Paris Pike, Lexington, KY 40505 | 38°4′49″N, 84°26′54″W — Directions: MapQuest

    A Roaring Twenties Idea

    Joyland opened on May 30, 1923, on the north side of Lexington, along what was then a fairly open stretch of Paris Pike. It wasn’t the Sauer family’s first venture into the business: they had already been running Bluegrass Park, an older trolley park off what’s now Versailles Road, since 1909, complete with its own wooden coaster, the Scenic Railway. Joyland was a bigger, more ambitious follow‑up. Frank Brandt handled general management; brothers John W. Sauer and F. Keller Sauer ran the rides. A fourth partner, A. M. James, took charge of the dance hall. Weekday admission to the grounds was free, with rides, games, and food priced separately, a fairly standard amusement‑park arrangement for the era.

    The owners softened that a little: Lexington’s orphans were invited in for free rides and games several times a year, and white children could take free swimming lessons at the park pool. The parking lot alone could hold close to five thousand cars, a scale that says something about how far people were willing to drive.

    The Wildcat and the Midway

    AI reconstruction of the Wildcat wooden roller coaster at Joyland
    The Wildcat roller coaster. AI reconstruction.

    The park’s signature attraction was the Wildcat, a wooden rollercoaster built in the late 1920s by Philadelphia Toboggan Coasters, Inc., a manufacturer still in business today and responsible for some of the country’s most historically significant wooden coasters and carousels. An undated, unverified period advertisement billed it as “½ mile of thrills.” Despite the marker’s singular billing, Joyland actually ran two coasters: the Wildcat and a smaller Kiddie Coaster alongside it. The rest of the midway filled in around them: a miniature railroad known as the Joyland Streamliner, a funhouse called the Barrel O’ Fun, built in 1948, and by the 1950s a separate attraction called Laff in the Dark, a swing ride called The Rocket, bumper cars, a carousel, pony rides, arcade games, a playground for children waiting their turn, and ball fields that hosted local leagues and visiting teams from other towns. Joyland also kept a small zoo, an odd but common feature of period amusement parks, with a bear, a monkey, a wolf, an alligator, and an anteater among the residents.

    AI reconstruction of The Rocket swing ride at Joyland
    The Rocket ride. AI reconstruction.

    The pool was the real civic milestone: it was Fayette County’s first public swimming pool, at a time when most swimming in the county still meant a creek or a private club. That same unverified advertisement touts it as filled with “drinking water,” a sanitary selling point of the era, and names a Stella Spicer as swim instructor, though neither detail has turned up anywhere else and should be read as color rather than confirmed fact.

    The park also served as an occasional stage for university life. In July 1945, the Kentucky Kernel reported that Joyland would host a “UK Day” for University of Kentucky faculty, staff, and students, tied to a fundraising push for the McVey Scholarship Fund, a small window into how thoroughly the park had woven itself into the lives of Lexingtonians by the mid‑1940s.

    Club Joy and the Big Bands

    The Club Joy Dance and Casino was Joyland’s evening identity. Despite the name, there’s no confirmed record of gambling machines on site, though rumors of something happening behind closed doors persisted without ever producing charges. What’s better documented is the music: cover charges ran 50¢ on weeknights and 75¢ on weekends, and the club booked touring acts alongside its house orchestra. Duke Ellington and Artie Shaw both played there, and Club Joy’s regulars, The Bluegrass Troubadours and Smoke Richardson and his Orchestra, filled out most other nights. Dancing reportedly ran “every night except Sunday.”

    Period newspaper advertisement for Joyland Park
    Period newspaper advertisement for Joyland.
    The Joyland Streamliner miniature train ride
    The Joyland Streamliner.

    Some acts reportedly went out live over the radio. If Club Joy’s shows really did air in the 1930s, the likeliest carrier was WLAP, Lexington’s only established station through that decade and into the ’40s, having relocated from Louisville in March 1934.

    For a stretch in the 1930s, Club Joy also hosted a “Miss Kentucky” beauty contest. The timing fits a national pattern: after the Miss America pageant’s own mid‑decade hiatus and 1933 revival, amusement parks, swimming pools, and theaters across the country became common local hosts for beauty contests riding on its popularity. Whether Club Joy’s version had any formal tie to the Miss America pageant isn’t clear from the surviving record. It may just as easily have been one of many locally run contests borrowing a familiar name, a common and largely undocumented practice at the time.

    A Segregated Kind of Fun

    The marker’s own wording, “the segregated park,” is doing real work, and it’s worth considering rather than passing. Joyland operated as a whites‑only venue by default. Black families were let in only on designated “special” days set aside for that purpose, and Black children were barred from the pool outright.

    When the Lexington Leader ran its free learn‑to‑swim program, white children took their lessons at Joyland; Black children were routed to Douglass Park’s pool instead, a parallel but separate facility on the other side of town. The program kept running at Joyland right up until the park’s last years: in 1961, just two years before closing, 705 girls enrolled and 226 earned their beginner swimming certification, a record for the program.

    Even the touring Black musicians who played Club Joy’s stage performed to a room they weren’t otherwise welcome to sit in. None of this made Joyland unusual. It reflected how public leisure in Lexington was organized for most of the twentieth century, part of a segregated park system that included places like Bluegrass Park and dated back to at least 1916.

    Decline and the Final Curtain

    The Sauer family, who also owned Bluegrass Park, sold Joyland in 1942 to a trio of new owners: Garvice Kincaid, M. C. Haddix, and Carl King, per University of Kentucky Special Collections records. Kincaid is the one name here with a documented afterlife. He went on to become one of postwar Kentucky’s most significant businessmen, the state’s youngest bank president at 32 years old in 1945, later the owner of Kentucky Central Life Insurance and the developer behind downtown Lexington’s Kincaid Towers, and by his death in 1975 the head of an empire estimated near $500 million. In 1942, none of that had happened yet; buying into a Paris Pike amusement park was one of his earliest capital ventures, years before the bank presidency or the insurance company. Haddix and King left no comparable trace in the record.

    The 1950s decline, thinning attendance, sections closing one at a time, competition from television, movie theaters, and larger regional parks, played out entirely under the Kincaid ownership group. By August 1963, the losses had piled up enough that the park shut down entirely.

    Fire, Bulldozers, and What Came After

    Roadside view along Paris Pike at the former site of Joyland Park
    Paris Pike at the former site of Joyland Park.

    Club Joy burned in a fire that gutted the building beyond repair. Some accounts date the fire to 1964; a surviving Kentucky Photo Archives photograph is captioned 1965. Either way, the building burned within a year or two of the park’s closing and was torn down soon after. Developers bought the land, cleared what remained, and built Mary Todd Elementary School and the Joyland Bowling Alley, which operated into the early 2000s. A residential subdivision went up around them and took the old park’s name: Joyland, the neighborhood that still carries it on the map, sits on the ground where the Wildcat once ran.

    Sources consulted: Kentucky Historical Society marker inscription (No. 2568, erected 2019); Kurt Robinson, “Joyland Park,” ExploreKYHistory; Historical Marker Database (hmdb.org); Roller Coaster Database (rcdb.com); University of Kentucky Special Collections Research Center, David Hooden photographs of Joyland finding aid; Kentucky Photo Archive; Kentucky Kernel, June 29, 1945; Joyland Neighborhood Association marker dedication record, April 2019.

    Buy Me a Coffee